Gold’s Friends Now Outflank Its Foes

In the Rick’s Picks chat room, where the focus is sometimes obsessively on gold, the meaning of “long-term” can range anywhere from 90 minutes to about three hours. Small wonder, then, that whenever Comex precious-metal futures hit an air pocket and briefly plunge, the shock waves wash over the room like a tsunami.  In fact, these fleeting episodes mean nothing, considering that the larger, bullish environment for gold contains more testosterone than a Chicago stockyard. Who needs to worry about what those nasty, retrograde bullion bankers, commercial traders and by-now impotent central banks are doing when you know for certain that the likes of China and India are size buyers?A-meaningless-23-swoon2

And they are, along with Russia, Indonesia, Arabia and every other sovereign entity that is not afraid to offend the U.S. with a defensive leap out of dollars. Under the circumstances, now that its fan club has grown to encompass the entire non-English-speaking world, gold can barely sell off any more. China is naturally gold’s biggest supporter, since the country supposedly holds three quarters of its $2 trillion cash hoard in dollar-denominated instruments, chief among them a mountain of Treasury paper. Since we know the Chinese didn’t get that rich by being stupid, we can be fairly certain they are not content to merely “hope” that the U.S. economy turns around, taking the dollar along with it.  This scenario is as implausible as a credit-financed auto-and-housing boom in the U.S., and they know it. And so we shouldn’t be surprised to find them quietly buying bullion whenever a large quantity is offered for sale. 

Subversive Ideas 

This type of buying does not typically drive gold quotes into a bullish frenzy; rather, it supports the market whenever prices turn soft. (There will always be big sellers around to make this happen — Great Britain, for instance, which treats sovereign gold as though it were radioactive. And why should they not, since, as long as a government stores the stuff as though it were valuable, the citizenry is bound to harbor the subversive notion that gold is itself money.) 

For our part, we can only look upon the mood swings that roil the chat room from time to time with bemused detachment. In the room, even when gold is rallying, the fear persists that THEY are going to pull the plug one day, sending quotes into one of those horrific tailspins that make gold bugs wish they’d stuck with stamps, coins or some other investable whose prices is governed by staid investors who clip coupons, tie flies and train carrier pigeons when they are not tuned to Prairie Home Companion.    

(If you’d like to have Rick’s Picks commentary delivered free each day to your e-mail box, click here.)

  • james e elbaor md November 28, 2009, 4:32 am

    Arabs wait til Ackerman away to lay oilless shell !
    Naturally, the Arabs announced their default in the dead night an Holiday with RA away to stun the masses !

  • Rich November 25, 2009, 6:19 pm

    “For every two private sector workers, one works for government. This latter third produces NOTHING, it is pure consumption leeching off the former two-thirds.”

    Add in AFDC, SSI and SSDI and we already have more than half the population depending on a minority of the population. And, thanks to reduction in payrolls, Social Security is already paying out more than it is taking in, let alone Medicare, which has been buggered by Free Drugs and Foreign Families. Not to mention the states of CA and HI under investigation for denying additional claims by furloughing workers on Federal salaries:

    http://www.ssa.gov/pressoffice/pr/dds-letter-pr.pdf

    Atlas is Shrugging.

  • Rich November 25, 2009, 1:06 am

    Aloha Chris T et al

    I sold my gold and silver because I do not trust trailing sell stops to get me out safely in times of mania. I may buy them back.

    I still hold Exxon Mobil. WEB sold his silver and bought some XOM.

    Saw your thoughtful post and attempt to respond in kind, begging the indulgence of Rick and other RA posters for this length with documented detail.

    In 2009 National Geographic reported a higher total global gold estimate of 161,000 tonnes.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold

    That’s some 5.7 B ounces of gold versus a $69 Trillion Purchasing Parity Global GDP.

    At that rate, one might expect gold to trade at or above $12,105 an ounce, as we said after the 1980 peak when we wrote Milton Friedman and Alan Greenspan about dollars versus gold and AG’s 1967 endorsement of the gold standard, his Gold and Economic Freedom essay in Ayn Rand’s Capitalism, The Unknown Ideal.

    http://www.usagold.com/gildedopinion/greenspan.html

    Martin Armstrong sees gold at $5000.

    http://www.martinarmstrong.org/files/GOLD-5000-11-11-09.pdf

    Most predictions are wrong, although Rick’s are more often right than most. Things change.

    China surpassed South Africa as the world’s largest producer.

    There may be no global gold production peak. There was no oil production peak, despite Paul Ehrlich’s Population Bomb, The Club of Rome’s Limits to Growth, global warming Kyoto Cap Trade, war and other schemes to justify more population control and taxes.

    There is gold in abandoned mines, Antarctica, Greenland, Iceland, the seabed and even seawater. At some price it becomes economic, if not political.

    China, like Russia now and the USA in the post-Civil War with Comstock and the Thirties with Homestake, is buying much of its gold from domestic production.

    We agree a significant quantity of global gold may be gold plated lead or tungsten. The price of gold may have already risen to discount this.

    http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article15143.html

    That is one reason Gold Eagles protected from counterfeiting by the Secret Service sell at a premium when they are available.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Gold_Eagle

    Various exchanges reportedly recently accepted 22 karat or less pure coin melt gold at a discount from for delivery to Asians after they refused 25% cash settlement premiums.

    http://news.goldseek.com/GoldenJackass/1259100000.php

    The NY Fed where Treasury Secretary Geithner was President, holds one quarter of the world’s gold reserves. The third Bruce Willis Die Hard movie was about robbing it:

    http://abcnews.go.com/print?id=5835433

    Gresham’s Law observed bad money drove out good since ancient coins were clipped. Alexander, Egyptian, Solomon, Inca gold was stolen, the US Constitution definition of gold and silver as legal tender was repudiated and perhaps Fort Knox, New York Fed, Denver, Philadelphia, San Francisco and West Point Mint gold was moved.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gresham%27s_law

    Gresham’s Law is the reason most central banks like the Federal Reserve keep physical gold, while lending dollars for bonds and stocks backed by electrons and faith. They may occasionally sell it when they think it is overvalued, one reason GATA accused them of manipulating the gold price.

    http://www.ecb.int/press/pr/date/2009/html/pr090807.en.html

    We note the current proliferation of hedge gold funds and paper gold funds including GDXJ with John Paulson bringing out a new gold fund in January. These big players apply leverage to the gold price that exaggerates movements to the upside and increases downside risk.

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/banksandfinance/6600825/John-Paulson-to-invest-250m-in-new-gold-fund.html

    No wonder gold went parabolic, with Trailing Sell Stops protecting terrific profits like BRYN and CDE. (Please note these are not recommendations!)

    http://www.goldalert.com/stories/Gold-Price-Surges-Toward-1200-5-Reasons-for-Golds-Bull-Market

    Is it possible the price of gold discounts all the bullish fundamentals including the dollar carry trade and is just trading on mania momentum?

    I saw gold spikes in 1971, 1980 and now. Two of the three were followed by gold crashes. Maybe this time things are different. Maybe not.

    Like oil, the last dollar refuge for big money, when things go parabolic, do they not sooner or later hit air pockets, particularly when retail trade is the most ebullient?

    Do we agree on that?

    http://www.cnbc.com/id/34121808

    We may disagree about the effect of Gresham’s Law on ersatz gold and paper gold ETFs.

    Gresham’s Law does not necessarily discuss leverage. Borrowed money is often the precursor to great declines with margin call induced selling, as we saw with Dot.com, Hunt Silver, Stock and Real Estate Bubbles.

    It is a singularly notable event when the IMF decides to sell 403 tonnes of gold, one eighth of their reserves, 12,965,649 troy ounces (12 Roman uncia/ounces per pound) with India buying almost half.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troy_ounce

    What frantic gold bull headlines luring lemmings to plunge do not disclose is that the IMF is selling gold accumulated since 1978 at much lower prices. Buy low and sell high makes money. Buy high and sell low does not.

    http://www.imf.org/External/NP/EXR/faq/goldfaqs.htm

    Despite mistakes made by Federal Reserve and Treasury Bankers at the expense of consumer citizens and taxpayers, not all investment bankers are fools.

    This is why the Big4 are 170% short gold and 450% short silver. Are they really naked shorts when big banks can borrow all the money they want from the Fed?

    http://www.cftc.gov/dea/options/other_lof.htm

    So far, George Soros is the only person we know who broke the Bank of England with his reflexive trading after losing a lot trading against GS on 20 October 1987.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Soros

    Now we have hysterical predictions of higher gold in 24 hours by professionals that often mark mania tops and career changes.

    http://www.zerohedge.com/article/gold-set-hit-1200-within-24-hours

    Even mass media headlines are ebullient, albeit hiding the fact the GLD holdings peaked out at 1134.03 tons last June 1st:

    http://www.smh.com.au/action/printArticle?id=918781

    Let us not forget China last Summer warned of defaulting on select underwater toxic commodity derivatives. This is hardly bullish for gold.

    http://www.reuters.com/articlePrint?articleId=USTRE5801UT20090901

    Combine that with the 49-week average maturity of US Treasurie3s that must be rolled over, plus growing defaults in hundreds of trillions of derivatives that dwarf gold, and we may have the making of interesting times.

    Why are the Big4 240% long the dollar? Do they have a death wish?

    Maybe someone can post a bearish current headline on gold to suggest it continues to climb a wall of worry?

    Or is gold now a religion for true believers?

    Your point on the export of America’s productivity is well taken and one with which I agree. Politicians long promised something for nothing. So your question about what productivity bonds, dollars (and stocks) represent is a good one.

    Warren Buffett and Bill Gates’ answers were that the best is yet to come. I work to have enough money to share their optimism.

    I agree with Steve Forbes’ observation that borrowing, spending and taxing our way to a weaker dollar that creates a weaker economy. He cited the example of Reagan and Volcker, who cut taxes and raised interest rates to protect the dollar and provide a better return on paper and industrial assets.

    Some observe than China, Japan and India want to build their factories here.

    Steve also observed that if a weak dollar were the answer, Argentina and Zimbabwe would rule the world.

    http://www.cnbc.com/id/15840232?video=1340401174&play=1 9:42

    Some argue that opportunity is long gone and it is too late to recover.

    I expect not.

    Based on half a century of participation in markets, I have learned to pay more attention to what people do with their money and less to what they say.

    Higher prices in gold lead to higher real interest rates and scarcer money and credit. Right now Bankers are tightening, and this is not bullish for most markets except bonds and dollars.

    I have often been early, one reason I read Rick and use Trailing Buy and Sell Stops.

    People tend to extrapolate recent performance.

    Yet there are still buyers and sellers to every market.

    People who can go against the crowd may make the most money.

    Meanwhile, the answer may be a transaction tax replacing income and payroll taxes on productive jobs and savings, with higher interest rates and a strong dollar signaling it really is time to Buy American as WEB said last Fall.

    I have no idea if that event is days, weeks, months, quarters, years or decades away.

    Meanwhile, deflation does seem to have more money on its side.

    By the way, both Dr Friedman and Greenspan responded they thought there were too many dollars to return to a gold standard.

    Regards*Rich

    http://www.jubileeprosperity.com/

  • Mitch P. November 24, 2009, 6:09 pm

    Chris T,

    Thanks for pointing that out. Some still don’t understand the gold story even after 8 years of a bull market. All those factors you mentioned are gold bullish, not bearish. $1500-2000 in the next 12-18 months looks very likely to me. And there is no such thing as a “gold bubble”. Roubini knows nothing about gold. He’s worse than the Nadler/Gartman types who have been out to lunch since $500 gold.

  • gary leibowitz November 24, 2009, 3:53 pm

    Rick,

    I used the word hyper-inflation perhaps misguidedly. I meant that double digit inflation will not come back. I, under any circumstances, would not expect true hyper-inflation to take hold. It is higly unlikely simply because most industrial nations are in the same boat as we are. A global depression will not single out our economy and currency.

  • ben November 24, 2009, 8:50 am

    How can you say the Chinese didn’t get that rich by being stupid? They worked and toiled, poisoned their land as well as their children, all to gather wealth. Now they have a trillion US dollars that they don’t know what to do with…if they try to spend a couple billion, the remaining hundreds of billions devalue rapidly. Meanwhile, they sit there and impotently watch the US government print, borrow, and spend what it does not have at the expense of China and other dollar holders. China did not look so smart recently when a Chinese official was begging America to protect China’s dollar holdings. The US government is a huge debtor, its people are huge debtors…what are the chances China’s dollar holdings will maintain their value when a devaluing dollar is good for both the debtor US government and the debtor citizens that vote for the government? China allowed itself to get into this Catch-22 situation out of stupidity. And even if they ultimately persevere….they will be taking a big hit to their national wealth.

    &&&&&&

    China knows that its IOUs from America are worthless and has already taken the hit, Ben, so it’s not a Catch-22 situation or even a dilemma. They can afford it. Looking beyond the coming global economic disaster, no one should doubt that China’s economy will be the first to emerge from Depression and that it will flourish with recovering Asian economies as trading partners. They will buy cocktail parasols, keychains and medical devices from the U.S. And, to concede the point, they will choke and die young on their foul air and poisoned water. RA

    RA

  • Chris T. November 24, 2009, 7:25 am

    Rich,

    as this is a belated post, you prob. won’t see it. however:

    you write:

    “When more of us realize they do not hold the unencumbered physical, or worse, hold gold plated tungsten, the gold game may be over.”

    Your statement is contradictory. Yes, the realization of fraud in gold, where unencumbered physical was sold but fake-paper-gold-promise were delivered, will turn some/many who want gold away = declining demand.
    BUT, the realization you mention will finally show that the supposed supply is MUCH MUCH smaller than most had thought. The tungsten alone has been purported to be about 12% of that mythical 150kt.
    Which will be greater, the decline in demand, or the decline in supply? I wouldn’t be so sure about the former. If these frauds prove true, the game may not fizzle, it may advance to the next level.

    This is not different than a bank run in a fiat system, where the same dollar has been promised to many. Those that have their cash out already (=those who hold real gold) are doing great vs. all those that stand in front of the locked bronze doors. (=those holding now-outed fake paper gold).

    This is deflation, sure, as the amount of money in the bank run example suddenly gets less, so appreciates, but so does the amount of gold suddenly get less, and so also appreciates.

    “Only wish we had more gold and stocks to sell for bonds and dollars in this deflationary Jubilee Winter season.”

    It may happen, but what is the compelling argument for US paper, bonds or dollars? What do they represent in terms of productive output? What do we still make in this country?
    For every two private sector workers, one works for government. This latter third produces NOTHING, it is pure consumption leeching off the former two-thirds.
    And of that former two thirds, how much is active in furthering consumption?
    Casinos, restaurants, the medical profession, hotels, and yes the housing industry (as you recently pointed out being consumptive)…

    Not much left as a compelling argument for our paper.

    Finally, cash and bonds are sandwiched between gold on the bottom and stocks above in Exters pyramid. The deflation in assets we read so much about here (derivatives, houses, stocks etc, etc), is crashing down onto bonds and cash, appreciating them. But the crash continues to the bottom layer, onto gold, appreciating it also.

  • Rich November 24, 2009, 12:29 am

    As Rick’s title suggests, it may be as difficult to find a golden bear today as a steer with testosterone;

    Since the inflammatory Trolls apparently left the building, offer the gentle observation that gold in Eurodollars or inflation has not set a new high in this deflationary environment, although it is close.

    Exactly how are surplus BRIC mercantilist nations going to hide their considerable assets ($69 T world PPP GDP) in all the gold ever mined, the entire 158,000 tonne 20.2 meter cube of which could fit on a basketball court, inside the base of the Washington Monument or a 25 yard swimming pool?

    Japan is on the verge of spending its surplus on seniors. While the Eurozone has a $15 T PPP GDP, and the USA $14 T, the USA economy is almost as big in real terms as China, Japan and India combined.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28PPP%29

    How well we remember how Japan was going to take over the world in 1989. Now China’s PPP GDP economy is bigger than Japan’s and Germany’s combined. Let us not confuse gold with power, prosperity or productive wealth as some do. Gold is bulky in the pocket, hard to hide, gets stolen, counterfeited, and goes down as well as up.

    Predictions of peak gold, negative interest rates, total bank failures, Treasury defaults, confiscation, hyperinflation, occupation by a foreign power, turning off the internet, weapons of mass destruction and the end of civilization may sell comic books. They simply have not materialized with the Midas hysteria.

    In fact, we are more bullish on Cattle, CO2, Corn, Crude and Wheat than gold.

    Exchange deliveries, Hedge or Exchange Traded Funds may be the swing voter on gold prices. When more of us realize they do not hold the unencumbered physical, or worse, hold gold plated tungsten, the gold game may be over. Nouriel Roubini sees just another speculative bubble that may burst spectacularly.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_as_an_investment

    We observe Asian markets which have been leading US may have topped out, anywhere from August SHI to September KSPI to October Nikkei to November HSI to STI today. That does not bode so well for American markets.

    Sir John Templeton used to sell at the point of maximum optimism. Charles Mackay concluded in his 1841 book, Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds: “Men, it has been well said, think in herds. It will be seen that they go mad in herds, while they only recover their senses slowly, and one by one.”

    Only wish we had more gold and stocks to sell for bonds and dollars in this deflationary Jubilee Winter season.

    Trailing stops are great to increase profits unless market air pockets hit as Rick noted from the trading room…

  • gary leibowitz November 23, 2009, 11:30 pm

    I wouldn’t put such high praise for the Chinese Intelligence just yet.
    History has a way of repeating itself but usually not during ones own lifespan. Human nature places the most current experiences as the most prominent ones when determining likely outcomes. Since the cause for deflation and depressions is so obscured by time its no wonder everyone is looking for hyper-inflation to be the end result of this massive Fed infusion.

    All bets are that the dollar gets trashed and hyper-inflation ala 70’s come roaring back. Can you imagine if they are wrong?

    &&&&&&

    The 1970s produced nothing remotely approaching hyperinflation, Gary. Read every word at the following link if you want to understand exactly what it takes to create a hyperinflation. None of the mechanisms that Germany had in place to do so after WWI are present in the U.S. right now; nor is the will to use them. Not one person in a million could tell you how Weimar printing-press money actually found its way into the economy. Read this and you will understand:

    http://mises.org/resources/4016

    RA

  • joe-- November 23, 2009, 6:59 pm

    Rick–

    Would you have said the same thing two months ago?
    I think not
    I think you are trying to say that India-IMF deal was a game changer (sorry about the cliche). And dittos for China since they have been put to shame by the Indians plus have been widely (quoted?) speculated to be buying on weakness thus making a floor for AU

    China being the number one gold producer?
    That came out of the blue, was very unexpected
    More “primitive” people like the Hindus and Chinese have a visceral love of gold and silver. Sophisticated Americans and Europeans have lost this for the time being …. Because we are entranced by the world of fiat money with all its plastic credit cards and buying houses and automobiles on credit. This world looks much jazzier, much more exciting, much better than the world of gold and silver coins. Food stamps are now doled out via swipeable plastic. More magic! More free money!

    Nations with fiat money pushed to the edge (USA) have all kinds of magically free money for its citizens. This magic all computes a lot better in the mind of Americans than gold and silver

    All until the SHTF. This is when this veneer of civilization gets stripped away and average Americans re-learn that instinct that gold and silver are very valuable and they become “primitive” like the Hindus and Chinese

  • Robert H. November 23, 2009, 6:36 pm

    Your phrasing (as in today’s post) including, ” … bullish environment for gold contains more testosterone than a Chicago stockyard.” and, ” …make gold bugs wish they’d stuck with stamps, coins or some other investable whose prices is governed by staid investors who clip coupons, tie flies and train carrier pigeons when they are not tuned to Prairie Home Companion.” is reason enough to thoroughly enjoy your daily posts – to say nothing about the underlying, remarkable prescience and value of your prognostications. Write on, Mr. A.

  • FranSix November 23, 2009, 5:54 pm

    Weekly Gold Chart Analysis.

    Gold has seen price turning points on schedule every two years for the last ten years, I assume its due to the bullion leasing regime. Based on the monthly chart, its probable we’ll see a major correction come spring. But the weekly chart has an interim target:

    http://stockcharts.com/h-sc/ui?s=$GOLD&p=W&b=5&g=0&id=p34298577235&a=156853006&listNum=2&listNum=2

  • keith November 23, 2009, 5:07 pm

    I heard an interview from Sinclair roughly 6 years ago. He said “it was not the gold guys who pushed gold to 887.50 back in 1980, it was the central banks that did it in order to balance the international balance sheet of the federal reserve.”

    It’s just interesting that now we are seeing a shift here in countries and central banks buying gold. As you said it should add support for any price drops for awhile. History may be repeating itself.

  • Andy November 23, 2009, 1:54 pm

    One simple question. Why is it to China’s advantage to have the dollar drop, thus reducing the value of its reserves? Only if China could convert reserves into something else can it avoid this, but there is nothing else to convert $2 trillion of US dollar reserves into. Same problem for everyone else. They can all buy gold, gold can soar, but the gold market is NOT controlled by central banks, so the private market could force the price to fall, thus devaluing the reserves held in gold. Why would central banks take on all that risk?

    Andy

  • Chris T. November 23, 2009, 10:31 am

    Hello,

    just another $8 to go to that long announced hidden pivot, then there are no more.
    Any motion in the crystal ball…