Bullion Bulls Needn’t Fear a Resurgent Dollar

Time for a reality check in bullion – and in the dollar while we’re at it – since anxiety about the price action in both seems to be rampant these days. The latter, as represented by the NYBOT Dollar Index, exceeded a bullish trigger price of ours yesterday by 0.02 points, causing some gnashing of teeth in the Rick’s Picks chat room. Gold and silver investments are quite popular in this forum, to put it mildly, and signs of strength in the dollar, however faint, are usually seen as threatening.  Before we get upset about the prospect of a resurgent greenback, however, let’s consider why it has been rallying in the first place.  Quite obviously, this has been a response to rumblings in Europe, where Ireland and Portugal have recently re-emerged as the financial basket-cases-of-the-month. We’ve seen this movie before, though, and that’s probably why the U.S. dollar’s upward adjustment has been relatively muted this time around.

Okay.  So now the dollar has breached three prior peeks without pausing for breath.  Should we be impressed?

There are other reasons as well. For even in a financial world that has been steeping for way too long in an economically fatal brew of delusion, stupidity and moral blindness, and in which, each day, cosmic quantities of Other People’s Money (OPM) are deployed in sham markets with wanton recklessness, the flight-to-safety story was becoming a difficult sell. Some of you may recall that the word “safety” was once used interchangeably with “quality,” as in “flight-to-quality,” when referring to the sandpiper-like shifting of global liquidity into dollar assets, most significantly Treasurys, in times of crisis. Nowadays, however, the word “quality” is rarely used in connection with the dollar because it would be an affront even to the village idiot’s intelligence – to Tim Geithner’s intelligence, for all we know.

Those PIIGS Again…

Not that such considerations would altogether discourage the OPM crowd from reflexively leaping back into dollars whenever Fitch’s says a discouraging word or two about the PIIGS.  And leapt they have, but to what effect?  In fact, the dollar’s rally has been unimpressive so far.  It did register a bullish “impulse leg” yesterday on the daily chart (shown above), but the process has been one of accretion. If the dollar’s current rally were destined for greatness, we should have expected it to come storming out of the gate – especially since the buck must be presumed spring-loaded due to a massive carry-trade that has effectively put the world’s financiers on the short side of the dollar.

If the rally should continue for perhaps a brief while longer, however, we would suggest that bullion bulls keep their cool by reminding themselves of the U.S. Treasury’s need to borrow at least $800 billion over the next six months.  And if that doesn’t seem scary enough – which is to say, bullish enough for gold and silver —  consider that it implies a $1.6 trillion annualized rate of debt expansion, all of it funny money. Contrasted with the recent emergence of pan-European, half-hearted austerity dictated by Germany, if not by penury itself, it is hard to imagine what currencies the U.S. dollar would be rising against in the febrile minds of bulls.

(If you’d like to have Rick’s Picks commentary delivered free each day to your e-mail box, click here.)

  • DarkestKnight November 17, 2010, 12:42 am

    “…it is hard to imagine what currencies the U.S. dollar would be rising against in the febrile minds of bulls.”

    – How about the Euro when the Germans get sick of the minor Euro countries needing bailouts, leading to the break-up of the EU? May sound far-fetched, but seems like anything is possible these days.

    • Robert November 17, 2010, 5:26 pm

      Portugal’s Finance Minister is already pontificating in the press about Portugal possibly leaving the Euro…

      Are the cracks forming?

  • gary leibowitz November 16, 2010, 10:41 pm

    The dollar is in fact being “talked down” by this and past administrations. In reality the 600 billion purchase of treasuries over the next 8 months is not going to change the credit situation much. On an annualized basis it amounts to about 7 percent increase. For the last 50 years 7 percent was the norm. We had our only contraction in 2009. This of course assumes the commercial banking credit remains unchanged. That assumption, given the recent trend should hold true.

    With China trying to cap their economic expansion, the Republicans holding the line on spending, and trade wars developing you can be sure the dollar will NOT fall from here.

    A perfect storm is developing that should see another round of steep equities drops along with most commodities, and a surprise run for the dollar. I personally don’t see this all happening until early next year.

  • Kelly November 16, 2010, 8:27 pm

    Hi all,
    I’m a geologist and it’s my business to know how much of each metal is in the ground, how much of it is accessible and how much is used by industry. What you may or may not know is that silver is unique as its surpassing other industrial metals in becoming rarer. So much of it is used and isn’t recycled, just thrown away and gone for good; in the coming years the above ground and below ground supplies will not continue sto upport industrial demand for it.
    The price of silver has been artificially kept low due to industries’ influence on government, since industry depends on the metal and there is no practical substitute for it; and we all know the bank(s) manipulate it as well. Again, as we all know, as with all commodities, the price should approximate the supply/demand principle, but speculators and regulations skew the real value. Based on the dependence industry has on silver, the real value should be twice what it is today and eventually the supply/demand principle will force silver to have its rightful value no matter what banks and government do.

    For those of you who are patient, my advice is to continue to accumulate silver when it hits regular lows as supplies continue to diminish. Even if demand remains constant the inevitable conclusion is that silver will perform brilliantly no matter what government does! Unless of course if government prohibits the personal possession of silver, which in the not too distant future may happen.

    Gold on the other hand isn’t used very much — most of it is stored because there is miniscule industrial demand for it. Why gold has such a high value, as a scientist, I don’t know, but from an investment standpoint gold is worth as much as people are willing to pay for it. I’m not anti-gold, I just don’t see any intrinsic value as the only demand placed on it comes from people’s desire to have it, instead of needing it.

  • Koichi Ito November 16, 2010, 7:06 pm

    Buy it! This is an excellent opportunity to buy Gold and Silver bullion as well as rare coins!

  • Rich November 16, 2010, 5:15 pm

    “Contrasted with the recent emergence of pan-European, half-hearted austerity dictated by Germany, if not by penury itself, it is hard to imagine what currencies, in the months to come, the U.S. dollar would be rising against in the febrile minds of bulls.”

    Beautiful vocabulary pictures Rick.

    Big4 long only American and Kiwi dollars. (Everyone wants to live down under now and pay taxes in Hong Kong.)

    Re-united Germany may be more powerful than a GE locomotive, but the deadbeat PIIGS and policies it is pulling may ultimately make it slide backwards down the Euro mountains while yodeling for help from American demand…

  • fallingman November 16, 2010, 5:08 pm

    “Nowadays, though, the word ‘quality’ is rarely used in connection with the dollar because it would be an affront even to the village idiot’s intelligence – to Tim Geithner’s intelligence, for all we know.”

    Haaaaaaaaa. Now that’s funny.

  • DG November 16, 2010, 4:12 pm

    I’ll go out on a limb here. (crack!)

    Doc Copper is looking extremely chipper lately. Fit. I don’t know that I have ever seen him so robust. It is hard to argue with $4 a pound. That’s the number. Is $4 the new $1.50? Just as $1.50 became the new $0.50? A $4 floor?

    I think copper bears watching. If, and that is a big “Ricky Bobby wagging his pointer finger atchya” If – copper can get through $4 then I think it will be clear to all that we are in monopoly money mania. Lets be honest. The price of copper has less and less to do with America and much more to do with the rest of the world with regards to demand. This is fact. The supply of US dollars is the major US price influence. If copper can get through the ceiling and create a new floor I think the message is clear.
    “Uncle Sam? It’s your banker. He says it is important. Something about your interest rate.”

    It is really easy math. 9% (going rate for Countries with credit scores less than 600 FICO) on $14 T is more than payroll income taxes. What then? Why stop at $4 copper. Or $25 silver. Or $100 oil. Or $14 for a cube of Costco TP. Or $1400 Au?

    Even if copper backs off here it will likely take a new run at $4. This is a 5 year process and this is the 5th run it has made at $4.

    Trust him. He’s a doctor. And by the way, his buddy, whom he always follows up and down, SCCO, says that $4 is in the bag. We’ll see.
    Just my worthless two cents. Which is worth 5.2 cents if pre 1982.

  • mario cavolo November 16, 2010, 12:25 pm

    Time for a reality check in bullion and the dollar with a side of Chinese vegetables….with veggie prices up SIXTY % and you’re gonna love this part, with NINETY % rises in garlic and ginger due to trading SPECULATORS!!! I knew this all months ago but MSM finally reporting it… Ok, so now its garlic, ginger and crude oil as the world’s staple commodities whose real prices are being distorted by speculators, maybe JPM will try a massive garlic short and Soros will try to corner the ginger market..what a world!! (FYI, heaps of garlic and ginger are used in daily cooking in China/Asia…)

    http://www.marketwatch.com/story/china-vegetable-prices-spike-60-on-year-report-2010-11-16

    Cheers all…nice to see my crude oil short making sense lately…Mario

    • Benjamin November 16, 2010, 12:58 pm

      “FYI, heaps of garlic and ginger are used in daily cooking in China/Asia…”

      Supposed to ward off vampires, too. So much for that!

    • Robert November 16, 2010, 11:26 pm

      So, Mario, what’s your “man on the ground” perspective on Chinese Gold demand following the recent rate hike?

      If price inflation in China is indeed getting too steamy, then are we to assume that the recent price declines in Gold are based on a shift in sentiment among chinese PM buyers? It seems to me like this is the story that the MSM is pushing after the recent Gold move- that this is the start of some Chinese Volcker-style move that will crush the gold bull, but I’m just not buying it…

      The paper market has been used to “fixing” the Gold price for nearly 40 years, because the physical demand environment never got in the way of the tight-knit cadre of traders in the bullion pits.

      You don’t have to be a Gold Bull yourself to recognize that there are more Gold and Silver Bulls today than there were a decade ago, or even a year ago. How can this new influx of buyers NOT be conducive to higher prices over longer periods?

      Sentiments aside, the size of this market alone is close to busting the doors open on the price fixing traders of old… these guys still think they are in control of the bullion markets, but the steam roller has already started bearing down on them.

      The lower the paper bullion shorts drive the prices, the more physical gets removed from the market and hoarded. The effect is a beach ball that that they are pressing on to hold it below the surface of the pool, but the more they press, the more air the beachball takes on. Eventually, the ball will re-float and knock off whomever is pressing down on it.

  • Ryan November 16, 2010, 11:29 am

    Silver just overshot its midpoint from it’s major cash spot high in 1980 of $48ish to its major low of $3.55 in ’93 of $25.75. So, $25.75 now becomes the area of consolidation, give or take a couple bucks either way. IMO, this is a major freakin’ midpoint here……and silver did overshoot it by like by 350 tics (still no comments)……..Wouldn’t that imply higher highs to come???? As far as the ratio staying below 50 btw gold and silver for the better part of 25 years………when’s the last time we had a currency crisis? Way more than 25 years ago…….and when people view silver as money and not as a commodity, the ratio will shrink.

    • Benjamin November 16, 2010, 6:18 pm

      Hi Ryan,

      I hadn’t considered the price so far back, but you’re right. That actually supports what I was saying… A consolidation period, for the next few months at least.

      As for _true_ ratios (not to be confused with Scotsmen!) I’ve come to conclude that there simply is no way to determine it, other than…

      It would depend entirely on what folks brought to the Mint for coinage. What they extend to the Treasury is what the ratio would be, and there would be no way (short of intervention) to “fix” it anywhere over any great length of time. That part of history should stay in the history books.

      So where would it go if? I have no idea! But I don’t exactly take the silver manipulation on the CRIMEX to mean a literal shortage. Silver would probably still be the most commonly coined metal, of the two.

  • Benjamin November 16, 2010, 10:23 am

    Whatever happens next, the gold/silver ratio has had trouble staying below 50 for the better part of the past 25 years. If my charts all went back so far and I could overlap them, I could give a more detailed analysis, but in more recent years seems when the ratio rises, the prices either drop or just don’t rise… for a while…

    That said, it’s not looking bad at all for either. I’m anticipating 24 silver in the weeks ahead, while gold seems pretty solid where it’s at. I’m betting that the ratio won’t go near sixity, going into next year.