Finally, a REAL European Bailout!

At last, the European Union has decided to do a USA-style bailout – one with a quintessentially American, trillion dollar price tag and a shining vision of success.  “[The agreement] will ensure that any attempt to weaken the stability of the euro will fail,” said European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso.  Yeah, but for how long?  We wonder if Mr. Barroso noticed that the euro finished on a downswing yesterday (see chart below), even as the ink on this latest deal was drying. Still, we hate to rain on the EU’s parade, and even if the Mother of All Eurobailouts failed to inspire a show of confidence in the euro, it nonetheless did pump up the world’s stock exchanges with  trillions of dollars’ worth of dubious new valuations. European shares registered their biggest single-day gain in a year-and-a-half, and U.S. stocks were not far behind.

June, Euro, Chart, FX, Forex

This bailout is a far cry from the paltry $60 billion credit line provided to Greece just a couple of weeks ago. We’d noted at the time that trying to do these rescue packages on-the-cheap would only invite doubt and derision. Probably the last thing those humorless stiffs in Brussels want is derision, and so no one should have been surprised to see them throw caution to the wind by ponying up a proper sum for a pan-European rescue. Greece will now be less likely to get kicked, punched and insulted when it heads for the discount window, and Spain, Portugal Italy and Ireland won’t have to worry so much that all of the rescue money will gone by the time Greece is done with it.

Soup to Nuts

It’s hard to say how long the good feelings will last, though, since we know from America’s experience that even a trillion dollars doesn’t go very far when the problem is perceived as bottomless. The cost of the U.S. bailout was estimated as high as $14 trillion, soup-to-nuts, and what did it get us besides a relatively modest blip in the Great Recession and a Fed balance sheet that remains a ticking time bomb . Would the bankruptcy of the PIIGs be an even bigger event than the collapse of the U.S. banking system?  We think the question is moot, since either would trigger the other. Meanwhile, we’re none too eager to short stocks at the moment, since, with the EU and Germany finally throwing in the towel on funny money, stimulus is headed toward a civilizational high. A trillion dollars in newly minted mind-money can only lower the threshold of what our best and brightest financiers perceive as “safety.”

(If you’d like to have Rick’s Picks commentary delivered free each day to your e-mail box, click here.)

  • TahoeBilly May 11, 2010, 10:31 pm

    Rick,

    Gold new highs in ALL currencies. Silver new highs in ALL currencies but the “greeny”. How is this not a slam dunk play dollar silver to new highs? If I had the big bucks, I’d be all in on a few more bucks in silver, no?? How more slam dunk does a trade get??

  • JohnJay May 11, 2010, 9:23 pm

    For what it is worth, I have read on one website their explanation for last weeks quick crash. They claim a big London hedge fund had placed very real sell orders on the off NYSE computer markets after a rumor that the head of Britain’s Central Bank was in favor of letting it all seek it’s own level since they can’t support it all for ever anyway. I have no idea if this is true, or how to look at the trades to see what happened.
    Possible?

  • Gary May 11, 2010, 5:52 pm

    Let us not forget that the 7th biggst economy in the World is …… California ! and how are they looking in the debt dept ?
    Maybe all the bullsh*t over the Euro is a bit of an overcooked smokescreen.
    If the mighty Dollar is supposed to be a safehaven in all this, give me a real currency instead … Gimme Gold !

  • Chris T. May 11, 2010, 5:29 pm

    “[The agreement] will ensure that any attempt to weaken the stability of the euro will fail,” said European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso.

    The derision should go to people like this (we have plenty like it in the US, remember the comittee to save the world triumvirate on Time magazines cover a decade ago?), who can make such obviously ludicrous statements, yet feel comfortable in knowing, that they and the mainstream all believe this to be true.

    What does a trill buy, a momentary 1-2 day blip in the currency to about 2%, and a transitory market bounce of a couple percent, to be less than where things were at only 5 trading days ago?

    If the best they can do is barely keeps things propped up, then the end-game is not too far off.
    Once, oh say starting about 1981, this kind of stuff was able to produce a real rush, see the markets from 1981-2000-2007, now it gets a flatline.

    Others have made the junkie analogy, and it is most apt. The drug initially produces a major kick, and because it is so good, he keeps coming back. Once addicted, all it really does is keep him from feeling lick s**t.
    If you remove it, he will feel the pain, and excruciating it is, but he will get better once weened off. [that is the “liquidate, liquidate, liquidate cure of Paul Mellon, and should have been done for Greece, AIG, etc, etc”]

    If you don’t remove it, there is no pain, but certain death.
    No one yet anywhere has removed the drug from the banks, the states, the countries, etc…

    • Mark Loeffler May 11, 2010, 6:25 pm

      Dear Chris,
      My thoughts exactly!

      Skol!

  • Rich May 11, 2010, 4:13 pm

    Friends and neighbors…

  • Rich May 11, 2010, 4:04 pm

    Twisters rule…

  • Rich May 11, 2010, 4:03 pm

    Turnaround Tuesday.
    Fundamentals trump neoKeynesian monetarism and rigged markets.
    Double Divorce: America and Europe, Main Street and Wall Street, for irreconcilable differences.
    Disintermediation from artificial assets to cash in hand an opportunity for shorts and inverse ETFs.
    Can’t fool mother nature or the invisible hand of the markets forever.
    Bot some DXD>24.46…
    Regards All*Rich

  • Mark Loeffler May 11, 2010, 3:31 pm

    Promises promises, promising a trill is one thing paying is another. By the time the money is needed who will be left to pay? Germany? the USA? China? Please, what a rediculous ploy to save a currency that few european countries actually want! The Germans are already going bonkers over this and Merkel will probably loose her job over it. Greece? Where is that? Let it fail let them default. The spiral is downward for years to come and the EU are now caught between default and devaluation. They will do whatever it takes to survive now but in the end they will not.

  • Jeff Kahn May 11, 2010, 1:57 pm

    As gullible and pollyanaish as people prefer to be, I think the sheer preponderance of crises is about to take its toll on investor psyche. How often can we keep printing trillions of dollars to insure that bankers keep their bonuses and union members can still retire at 55? Even the CNBC analysts of the world are getting suspicious, Even Sheeple know when they’re getting soaked.

  • Other Paul May 11, 2010, 5:45 am

    The graph of the euro doesn’t tell me about the effectiveness of the plan to save the euro.

    Where would the euro be without the weekend agreements? Do we know whether anything but words were the weapons of choice on Monday? If only words kept the euro from sub-1.25 readings, I’d say that the powers-that-be were pretty effective. Wait until the they throw “real” euro electronic mouse clicks at the problem.

    Heck, look at Japan. Twenty years of spend, spend, spend, an enormous Debt to GDP ratio, and look what was the go-to-currency on Friday–the Yen. Maybe Euroland and the US have got more Debt to GDP room to grow into.

    When the prices of physical PMs de-couple from paper PMs’ prices, we’ll know its the end for Tom Paine’s “Mike.”

  • Occdude May 11, 2010, 5:14 am

    Well this isn’t exactly a done, done deal. The hapless German peasants have yet to fully realize they’ll be providing the champagne and all the dishes Greeks can break. Their left wing nuts smell a rat and have made progress in the latest elections. Something tells me Merkel is not long for this political world. Meanwhile in Blighty…..They’re next up on the serving block and one can only imagine the bailout they’ll command, and don’t forget the land of the rising debt level errrrr sun, when the tab comes due for them lets just say that it will leave a mark, but at least they owe it to themselves.

    The game plan, expand credit to fill in the enormous gaps deflation hath wrought till the minimum monthly payment is exhausted, then print away….

  • Tom Paine May 11, 2010, 1:52 am

    Derision is what the “humorless stiffs in Brussels” deserve by suggesting that throwing a trillion Euros of “good money” after bad should somehow be seen as supporting their currency. Of course I put “good money” in quotes because it is all intrinsically worthless, which is the only reason they can work this QE magic anyway.

    I notice “da scuzballs” as Rick is wont to call them took the opportunity to take some gold away from the hapless dupes who fell for the idea that this is support for the Euro, not to mention how they unloaded a bunch of Euros on another set of hapless dupes.

    Oh, it would all be so funny if it wasn’t so tragic. I mean I didn’t buy any Euros or sell any gold. Nevertheless, it is hard to take any joy in watching the system unravel.

    Perhaps we should thank God for all the sheeple who still take slogans like “full faith and credit” seriously. After all, even though the metaphor seems backwards, they are the little bit of brainstem that might keep our “Mike the Headless Chicken” financial system alive long enough for the rest of us to prepare for the inevitable day when Mike keels over and dies.