Silver’s Sharp Selloff No Cause for Concern

Silver quotes have come back down to earth with a thud, so perhaps it’s time to review our outlook, which was, and still is, quite bullish for both the intermediate and long-term. The Comex July contract has shed a hefty 10 percent of its value since Tuesday, settling at 17.51 yesterday after peaking just two days earlier at 18.89. Although this has caused some gnashing of teeth and sporadic expressions of anguish in the Rick’s Picks chat room, long-term bullion players who frequent the room seem to be taking the move in stride.

We ourselves sounded an especially bullish note a week ago when we wrote that it would be a “piece of cake” for Comex silver futures to push above some daunting reservoirs of supply on the intraday charts.  The June contract duly obliged shortly thereafter, but as you can see in the May futures chart below, the rally left one key high at 18.91 recorded in January undisturbed. Although climactic buying missed exceeding that peak by just 2.5 cents, it was enough to make any selloff that followed a possible threat to the short-term picture.

That threat was “actualized,” as they say, by this week’s steep selloff, but it remains to be seen how much more damage will be done. So far, it is minimal, and we therefore still expect the futures to hit a very bullish 21.53 by mid-June. That is our target for the July contract, and it was mentioned in last week’s commentary along with a secondary target at 20.21. At what point would our outlook turn intermediate-to-long-term bearish? That would take a print below 13.89 (!), since, according to the rules of our proprietary Hidden Pivot trading system, that’s what is required to turn the weekly chart bearish.  With respect to the daily chart, the July futures need only dip below 16.590 by Friday to hint of serious trouble. That’s hardly unlikely, but even if it were to occur we would give the long-term bullish trend the benefit of the doubt until such time as the weekly chart confirms the negative.

Six Weeks of Purgatory

In the meantime, we’ll view the futures as being in purgatory, tasked with consolidating for the expected push within six weeks or less to 21.53.  Our position in silver at the moment consists of 800 shares of Silver Wheaton stock with a cost basis of 11.75.  We have been doing covered writes against the stock to further reduce its cost basis and, in line with this strategy, are short eight May 18 calls for 0.64.  If you’d like to tune in to Rick’s Picks daily analysis and predictions, you can sign up for my newsletter and receive one of my forecasts free each day; or consider taking a risk-free trial of the full service, which includes all of my forecasts and access to my chat room.

(If you’d like to have Rick’s Picks commentary delivered free each day to your e-mail box, click here.)

  • BDTR May 7, 2010, 5:08 am

    Ah, the breathtaking wonders of a full-flash-frontal assault of algorithms applied to the exquisitely indelicate designs of banksters, their salivating sidekick joker-broker lieutenants and legions of vacant eyed, silicon pumping technozombies! In your toothless face SEC! Up your legal wazoo DoJ! Mess with the maestro’s of malfeasance and their mystically-mathematical-manipulators and you’re a footnote to a doormat.

    But the fund managers that were finally stopped out only when prices hit pennies by relying on inferior technologies and misinformation, have cleaned out their desks and cancelled summer plans. Shell shocked traders whose own electronic tools inexplicably betrayed even their basest instincts and cynically seasoned reactions are heads down right now on a South Street bar, glazed as a East River sheen. Pensioners mourn the mounting dead.

    Hundreds of billions of shrinking electron dollars were parted from pixel pockets today for want of common or technical or market-sense, or in understanding that games of confidence are conducted at warp speed by a too well connected, highly criminal class of soulless, parasitic plutocrats,….in broad daylight,…. because of,… (gasp) Greece. (Who would have argued that it was BP, in the drawing room, with a gun?)

    They’ll be lining up again tomorrow to suck the vestige lifeblood of a critically anaemic republic’s marketplace.

  • ben May 6, 2010, 11:38 pm

    ” Our position in silver at the moment consists of 800 shares of Silver Wheaton stock with a cost basis of 11.75 ”

    Nice to see you have so much faith in your call on silver. I think my grandmother has a bigger position in a shoebox under her bed.

    &&&&&&&

    Faith isn’t the important thing here, nor even the absolute amount of any profits eventually achieved; rather, the position was initiated to guide others in timing their entry, and then to track and adjust as SLW fluctuates within a long-term bull market. If some subscribers hold a multiple of 800 shares, then more power to them. Usually, it is implied that any stock or option that I recommend be acquired in mutiples of four. I made an exception for SLW because I liked it so much. RA

  • johnjay May 6, 2010, 10:00 pm

    Right about 1:46 PM Chicago time Dow futures and bond futures reversed course. Euro futures too. Amazing.

  • Rich May 6, 2010, 9:13 pm

    Lots of internet trading platform outages…

  • Rich May 6, 2010, 9:13 pm

    Who was that masked man?
    (Re the 1000 point selloff this PM)

  • johnjay May 6, 2010, 9:05 pm

    Wow. Dow futures bounced right off the lower band of a high/low moving average for a monthly chart. 9823 by my E-Quotes chart for the lower band.

  • Robert May 6, 2010, 7:44 pm

    In 2004, Robert “Buddha” Gomez and James Nichols fleeced thousands of people to the tune of 21 Million dollars by selling these people “paper” automobiles…

    http://www.caranddriver.com/news/car/05q2/review_god_wants_you_to_roll-car_news

    These two hucksters swindled people into paying real money for (nonexistant) cars that were part of the fabricated estate of a fictional eccentric millionaire, who declared in his will that these cars were only to be sold to “decent, churchgoing people” at unheard of bargain basement prices as low as $1000.

    Why do I mention this story? Because the fraud that underlies this scam bears no fundamental difference to the fraud commited against the world via the bullion futures markets by the IMF, American Bullion Banks, and Major Western Central banks including the Federal Reserve and The Bank of England.

    A futures contract is merely a paper promis to deliver bullion at some future date- analogous to the paper promise to deliver a car at some future estate settlement date- and as long as the paper promis can be sold to a willing buyer, then the scam continues.

    But, where Gomez and Nichols were eventually hung out to dry when the need to deliver real cars to settle these purchase agreements came due, The Gold market scam is aided and abetted by a regulatory environment whereby the threat of default is curtailed simply by raising the number of allowable paper promises (aka position limits) that can be issued by willing sellers. As these position limits increase ever higher toward infinity, the legal ability to sell “Gold that grows on trees” only influences the sellers to be more bold and more deeply entrenched in the fraud….

    And we wonder why Jesus chased the money-changers out of the Temple?

    If the Gold Market runs at 10Trillion dollars per year, and yet the current dollar value of all the Gold ever mined rings in at about 800 Billion, then price manipulation is not a matter of opinion- it is an academic fact, especially when analyzed against the supporting fact that the US Fed could legally and conceivably sell 6000 tons of Gold to the IMF today as nothing more than a ledger entry backstopped by COMEX futures contracts, and whatever price they declared on the COMEX transaction would become the spot price instantly.

    Alas, where Robert Gomez and James Nichols were eventually brought down by people who became impatient with their expectation of physical delivery of the car that they “purchased”, so will the expected recipients of physical bullion eventually reach the same level of impatience (unless they are really stupid people who actually prefer owning potentially worthless COMEX contracts over cash or physical metal)

    Watch the video on LewRockwell’s site of Bill Clinton acknowledging that the current mess was caused by Fed issued soft money that ran rampant without the discipline of the Gold standard. Great stuff:

    http://www.lewrockwell.com/blog/lewrw/archives/56731.html

    Call me a member of the tin-foil hat crowd, but don’t call me an idiot- because I know fraud when I see it, and it doesn’t have to be tungsten filled to be obvious.

    If there is no fraud in the Gold Market, then Robert Gomez and James Nichols should still be free men, because all they did was sell future contracts against automobiles that they did not own. Ask yourself how this is any different than the Gold futures trading on the COMEX?

    Everyone should support commodity trading policy reforms that force physical collateral obligation when issuing future delivery contracts on the commodity exchanges.

    Please write your Senator today.

  • Rich May 6, 2010, 5:48 pm

    Silver’s Sharp Selloff No Cause for Concern…?
    What about margin calls or stop sells as prices collapse?
    Great call on SLW Rick…

  • Chris T. May 6, 2010, 3:33 pm

    “…makes it cheaper to borrow money to buy gold futures and obtain a guaranteed return than it is to have to pay interest to lease bullion and sell it into the market.”

    Always assuming that no physical delivery is desired, because, at least supposedly, the leasing/selling has so far involved an actual physical transfer.

    [Are the leased quantities actually physically removed from the lessor’s posession, or just treated the way unallocated gold accounts are, thus the buyer keeps his gold at the lessor’s vault (mainly CB’s)?.]

    Getting that transfer from Comex, etc is fraught with so many problems, its not comparable. That “”guaranteed return” will vanish quickly if (when?) force majeur or delivery default is declared.

    In the purely wood-pulp domain, you are right of course.

  • FranSix May 6, 2010, 2:46 am

    I’m watching closely here, as a major adjustment in the gold/silver ratio may occur.

    What caught my attention is the very brief jump in short term lease rates in bullion, which exceed the policy lending rate of .25%. That means theoretically that any federal replacement lending for commercial bank lending makes it cheaper to borrow money to buy gold futures and obtain a guaranteed return than it is to have to pay interest to lease bullion and sell it into the market.

    That means that the face value of gold leases are declining while the gold price rises, a very unusual situation.

    Silver leases by contrast are in consistently in negative territory, so this will make a huge difference in how gold and silver will be traded, should there be a decline in the discount rate. (though it may begin to catch up later)