Supercommittee Failure Just a Petty Distraction

We view yesterday’s stock-market plunge as unrelated to the failure of the not-so-Supercommittee to compromise on a paltry $1.2 trillion in budget cuts over ten years. No one expected a deal in the first place, and even if there had been one, its effect on the economy, let alone on the deficit, would have been negligible. Who would ever have believed even a decade ago that a “mere” trillion dollars in Federal outlays would hardly be worth arguing about? Still, the way stocks fell, one might have inferred investors actually cared about the outcome. The nightly news pretended it mattered, perhaps because there were no titillating alternatives to serve up on a slow-news day. Wall Street did its patriotic bit as well, feigning concern by sending the Dow Industrials 250 points lower. In fact, there was bound to be a little knee-jerk selling by institutional traders fearful that their competitors would be selling “on the news.” In our view, markets are driven higher, lower, and sometimes nowhere by mysterious cyclical forces that we will never quite understand. Moreover, it is the cyclically driven price swings that color our perceptions of the news, not the other way around.

Trumped-up headlines aside, one thing likely to send a wave of genuine fear through Wall Street is the impending failure of Europe’s deadbeats to get Germany to bail them out.  And, make no mistake, it is only Germany that could be imagined big enough to pass itself off as a credible savior for all of Europe. France is usually treated as Germany’s co-equal in bailout discussions, but in fact France is not a significantly better credit risk than Italy or Spain at this point. Under the circumstances, the unelected bureaucrats who purport to manage Europe’s affairs are hoping to gain support for a eurobond that would be seen as spreading the risk of a default across many nations.  Since most of those nations are financial basket cases, however, it is only the mountebanks and Ponzi operators who run the political institutions and banks who could even pretend such a strategy will work.

Germany’s Decision

What we should expect instead is for Germany to veto any thinly disguised attempt to paper over Europe’s debt problems, American-style, with two or three trillion euros worth  of new eurodebt – debt that presumably would be “purchased” by a bankrupt banking system. The decision would have grave implications for the German economy, since it would create a two-tiered currency system in which “bad” money would circulate in the deadbeat countries while hard currency – presumably euros – would remain the unit of exchange for Germany and a few other sovereignties still viewed as solvent. Having to sell Mercedes Benzes and Siemens machinery in hard money would put enormous strain on the otherwise robust German economy, probably sending it into recession. Still, if forced to choose between Belgium’s quack remedy and one that would allow the default chips to fall where they may, we predict the Germans will opt for the painful solution that alone will allow the financial system to right itself.

***

(If you’d like to have Rick’s Picks commentary delivered free each day to your e-mail box, click here.)

  • david casciano November 23, 2011, 9:32 am

    The financial system is collapsing,regardless of whether you are an inflationist or deflationist.if deflation.fed will print.Note IMF is funded 70 percent by FED.They increased credit lines to europe through IMF.If inflation ,FED will stop it as we will default if we dont buy treasuries /dollars to reduce interest rates or we default.KISS principle,buy physical sipver not gold as they may steal gold from you.AG is the trade of this decade as per Eric Sprott.!!!!!!Its simple as negative REAL INTEREST RATES ARE ALWAYS BULLISH for gold and silver.You all talk so much with ego and bull crap but simplicity is elegance.Buy phys. AG and ho;d for 5 years and live life, love life and give to life and i promise you will be a better person and wealthier

  • Blindfolded Monkey November 23, 2011, 3:09 am

    It wasn’t a failure. Both sides got what they wanted. The Democrats wanted the Bush tax cuts to expire and the Republicans wanted cuts to entitlement programs. They also have the benefit of saying they didn’t agree to the parts that their constituents don’t like.

  • C.C. November 22, 2011, 10:23 pm

    “They tried the tanks and guns unification method a couple of times before and got the snot kicked out of them both times. Why not try a unified currency with banks and credit instead of tanks and guns?”

    In point of fact, if it were not for a couple of supremely bad decisions by an ego-maniac regarding the importance of a few key battlefronts, the truth of the matter is that we would be Eating their ‘snot’, rather than kicking it out of them… Something to consider and be thankful for. Providence and timing were the deciding factors for the allies, not our superior ‘snot’-kicking abilities –

  • Seawolf November 22, 2011, 9:55 pm

    Jon Corzine being questioned by the SEC, CFTC, and the FBI

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CSe38dzJYkY&eurl=unknown&feature=player_embedded

  • Aussie Mick November 22, 2011, 7:56 pm

    There will be a New World Order..where countries become irrelevant…the UN is already run by the Bilderberg Group…those that control the money..Big Banks/Big Biz/Big Pharma…and their owners…like Rockefeller/Rothschilds…are keeping the ‘con’ going as long as possible to extract what ever is left from the ‘sheeple’…their savings…pension funds..super…while they finish their preparations. The Wall street gang will be hung out to dry..which is what they deserve…the USA will be ‘spent’…the money is gone…the young men will be spread around the world doing the bidding of NATO…any surviving americans will be in ‘tribal groups’. The first to be eliminated will be the aged..the infirm..the broke and destitute…the NWO will have no use for them. The American people deserve what is coming…they have allowed their Govt. to rape and pillage the world…bend over..it is your turn. Bit of a BUMMER eh? That’s what you get when you have a black puppet in charge..his handlers would be proud of him…

    • Buster November 22, 2011, 9:29 pm

      I try not to get into the blame game, personally, though I do get where you’re coming from. To be fair, the elitists have made fools of so, so many countries that they have leeched off of & fooled into fighting their battles. There have been plenty of willing thugs of all nationalities who have fallen for the idea that their gang has the right to pillage someone for whatever justification they’ve been fed. There are many ex-servicemen now speaking out about the atrocities being inflicted for no just cause, too.
      I don’t doubt that in time we’ll all come to understand that we are all viewed as the enemy by the 1%.
      In the desperate place we are all headed, I think it is important to keep an ‘inclusive’ way of thinking, & not let the terrible knowledge we have harden us to forget our humanity.

  • Seawolf November 22, 2011, 7:10 pm

    Of course Germany is going to veto option #1, the bailout. A bailout would mean that Club Med would owe even more money when they can not even service their current debt and in this case the money could not even used to buy more German goods. That is just throwing good money after bad.

    Let’s try option #2, writing off the debt. That one really goes against the German psyche. They want their money. The Germans need customers and who will loan the Club Med countries more money to buy German goods after a default?

    The Germans would like a third option. Let’s call it the real estate option. Germany has not given up its dream of a united Europe with the capital in Berlin. Why else would they have joined the Euro?

    Germany would really like to foreclose on Greece. They could move some of their efficient manufacturing facilities down there to take advantage of cheap, indebted Greek labor. Life would be good and as bonus there is all that now very cheap Greek beach property.

    They tried the tanks and guns unification method a couple of times before and got the snot kicked out of them both times. Why not try a unified currency with banks and credit instead of tanks and guns?

    • Buster November 22, 2011, 9:47 pm

      Let’s not forget that WW2 came about as a direct result of the overburdensome debt payments put on Germany after WW1 by the international Banksters. It was the economic fall out from this that allowed Hitler to get the support he needed to take power. Isn’t that ironic when you look at the riots across Europe over the debt burdens today. This is the real reason why Hitler singled out the Jews, as they were seen as the Bankers. That anger against the Banksters was poured out on innocents.

      And here we all are today, all suffering from overburdensome debts to the international Banksters…there’s nothing new under the sun really, it’s just that the game gets bigger & more efficient at feeding the beast.

      &&&&&&

      For the record, and as far as I’m aware, Deutsche Bank CEO Josef Ackermann is NOT Jewish, nor is he related to me. RA

  • Seawolf November 22, 2011, 6:25 pm

    Here comes more economic contraction. Oil prices are not going to go down.
    http://news.goldseek.com/GoldSeek/1321895391.php

  • ken horn November 22, 2011, 5:54 pm

    the financial situation that is emerging in the international markets appears to be the worst of both worlds- stagflation. real wage buying power will continue to erode, but the cost of buying essentials like food & fuel will rise. I think the recent action in the gold & oil markets is a short term head fake. the “average joe” will continue to see the equity in home languish & the value of his savings/investments decrease. At the same time, we will see considerably higher prices in all energy products, gold & essential food products.

    • gary leibowitz November 22, 2011, 11:46 pm

      Third world growth is contributing to the commodity bubble. Most will probably disagree. You can never have stagflation again based on the anti-union, less government paradigm. Without pressure from organized unions there will be no wage increase that will compensate for real cost increases. Without a voice in Wahington governments workers will be reduced, along with wages. Welcome to true capitalism. Let the markets decide on wages and employment needs.

      The Fed is posturing on QE3. How does it get passed with the majority hard liners? Too little, too late.

      The true definition of deflation IS being felt by homeowners with negative asset values. This will spread to all segments of the economy once corporations try to increase their profit by once again reducing the work force.

      Does anyone understand the ramification of the EU crisis? Corporate profits will be scaled down dramatically in the next 2 quarters.

      I sure hope we have that Santa rally. It would be a great opportunity to reduce exposure and bet on the dark-side.

      I am looking at SPX at 1185 as one support and 1155 as the next. It might even happen tomorrow. 1155 and I load up for one nice 6 week rally.

    • mava November 23, 2011, 4:10 am

      “The true definition of deflation IS being felt by homeowners with negative asset values. This will spread to all segments of the economy once corporations try to increase their profit by once again reducing the work force.”

      Which is…? The true definition of deflation is…?

  • Robert November 22, 2011, 5:33 pm

    Deflation, deflation, deflation….

    How about “economic contraction?

    Who dares to debate the difference between these terms with me? They are NOT the same.

    Q3 GDP prints at 2.0%

    Q3 M1 forecasted to increase, while Q3 M1 velocity is forecasted to decrease:

    http://seekingalpha.com/article/305571-m1-q3-gdp-and-interpreting-money-flows

    This is not deflation (by either definition): prices are NOT decreasing (have you filled your gas tank this week?) and money supply is NOT contracting.

    Money velocity relates to price stickiness moreso than general pricing levels. If money velocity continues its downward trend, then the economy will continue contracting- no doubt about it, but prices will only respond in kind if inventory levels really start cranking up.

    Meanwhile, the Gold price is behaving like this year’s Diwali Festival in India was a bust (which it wasn’t) and an infinite new supply of in-ground Gold has been discovered (it hasn’t).

    The signals for “deflation” are too obvious. It’s time to get long everything that only comes from the ground via hard work, because the best jobs of the next decade are only going to be in the productive sectors.

    What we are seeing is nothing more than a tug of war between the Fed (who wants the banks to start dis-hoarding and start lending) and the banks (who are perfectly comfortable borrowing from the Fed at .125% and buying long dated US Treasuries that pay 3%.

    Meanwhile, lending is actually irrelevant because no one is interested in taking loans anyway except for the people who would like to move up to nicer house, but can’t because the only way out of their existing house is to default on their underwater mortgage.

    Seems we are in secular bear market for greater fools… Except for the ones in Washington that think that government activity creates money and wealth.

    The Entrepreneur market also seems pretty bearish right now.

    This morning there was an exchange between Rick “Clearly I get it” Santelli and Steve “I may be the dumbest person on television” Liesman about the GDP number.

    GDP at 2% with “core inflation” also at 2% and cpi inflation creeping up toward 3% is a net loser for the US.

    Liesman asks “how will government raise revenues” (facetiously exposing the “raise taxes” argument again) and Santelli (in classic fashion) says:

    “When your spouse spends your budget into the ground, is the best solution for YOU to go get another job?”

    • John Jay November 22, 2011, 9:50 pm

      Robert,
      In certain areas of the economy government intervention is all that is delaying massive deflation.
      If we get rid of the home mortgage interest deduction, Fannie/Freddie/FHA etc. as well as ZIRP, house prices are headed back to 1980 prices. The one bright spot in CRE is warehouse space for CME type metals storage. It seems warehouses are stuffed with steel, copper, lead etc. As far as crude oil prices, with a sincere effort we could convert autos to alcohol in the USA and send crude oil demand reeling. Student loans are supporting the college tuition inflation.
      Big Pharma and the FDA makes sure no one ever is cured, only eternally ill. All this inflation is being financed with debt that can’t be paid back. This inflation will evaporate as soon as the government does. I have, however, no idea when that will be.
      But government jobs are being cut at the local and state level more and more, since thay can’t print money. And that is a good start to the end of fiscal insanity.

    • Robert November 23, 2011, 6:00 pm

      “In certain areas of the economy government intervention is all that is delaying massive deflation”

      Ummmm…. which ones, JJ?

      The gov’t makes travel MORE and MORE difficult to engage in via the TSA/Border Patrol, and yet airline booking rates are not collapsing.

      Home prices? Deflationary? hmmm… What about natural supply and demand? Does a natural glut of supply no longer impact price stickiness in this awesome new progressive world of ours?

      Gasoline prices: deflationary?

      Corn Prices: deflationary?

      Vehicle/equipment prices: deflationary? Last I checked US taxpayers subsidized General Motors and Chrysler 3 years ago so that they could raise their average prices by 5%+ over the same timeframe.

      The prices that are falling are in consumer electronics, and to call this deflationary is to ignore the entire concept of margin of diminishin return.

      Perhaps the reason prices on big-screens is falling is simply because this planet does not require 30 different brands, and 30 different sizes, and 5 different HD technologies….

  • gary leibowitz November 22, 2011, 4:21 pm

    Imagine the day when the United States would be chastising the EU for not getting its debt problem in order. Just because we had a head start on them doesn’t mean we are out of the woods. In fact after 3 years of “stabilization”, we are still not addressing how to balance our own yearly budgets.

    The impasse from the super-committee makes sense. I actually expected this result. Wall Street will not give a hoot since the mandatory cuts have been smartly placed for political cover. I just wished they tripled the mandatory cuts.

    If you have noticed the markets don’t want a real draconian spending policy. A small cut with a slow down in debt accumulation is just fine by the markets.

    Any large austerity measure would kill the financial markets. In affect either our Govenment passes such a policy or the American people, already choked with high costs and low wages will do it for them.

    The end game is here. This year or next makes no difference. Deflationary pressures are already being telegraphed by commodity price behaviour.

  • John Jay November 22, 2011, 4:16 pm

    The DC gang in the cockpit of this aircraft will keep pulling back on the control yoke all the way into the ocean. Just like those three Air France pilots. It doesn’t matter how many stall warnings are going off, their minds are locked, we are doomed.

  • dan November 22, 2011, 3:52 pm

    things are bad….they will get very bad sooner then later…

    • Buster November 22, 2011, 9:50 pm

      I always like to look on the bright side….

      At least things aren’t yet as bad as they’re gonna’ get!!

  • mava November 22, 2011, 7:34 am

    Germans…

    So many times have I heard this argument that Germany needs trading partners to sell their products to, and then consecutively, that it may make sense to bail those partners out.

    I’d like to point your attention to this though then: If it makes sense to bail out your trading partner, then why wouldn’t it make sense to just “bail out” the population of Germany, by giving them all these printed trillions, so that they can purchase all of those nice things that Germany produces?

    At least in this case, the wealth would stay in Germany, just the same as it worked for USA. Let the rest of the Europe have only the diluted Euros, and no BMWs.

    Of course, the industry is going to then leave the German borders, just like it left ours (there is always a price for magic). But hey, at least they wouldn’t be directly paying to build a competing industry in lazy nations.

    • Seawolf November 22, 2011, 3:11 pm

      It would not make sense to “bail out” the German population because they have already been bailed out. German banks lent money to Greece so that the Greeks could buy German products, which they did. That money then went back to Germany to be paid out as wages to German workers who then bought all those nice German products. The Germans have their products free and clear and the Greeks have German products and a German debt.

  • mava November 22, 2011, 7:25 am

    An excellent thought, Rick! Wow, thank you!

    Of course. Now let me to continue. So what does this mean that the markets actually cared for this paltry cut? I think if they did care, this means that the market participants are mostly brainwashed, and do not understand the gravity of the situation. Their estimate of a fix is way below the reality. And this, in turn, means that the situation has not been “priced in”, it means that the collapse of an unexpected scale can begin anytime.

  • RichardB November 22, 2011, 4:17 am

    Perhaps you meant the Stupor committee?

    I thought there might be some impact from this thanksgiving turkey, until it was pointed out that one congress can’t impose automatic cuts on the next one. Also, the president will veto any cuts to the military. I read that as business as usual and both sides just took a page from Europe and booted the can down the road.

    The people of the US better elect a clear winner next year or things could get bad.

    • VegasBob November 22, 2011, 5:54 am

      It’s too late to prevent things from getting bad.
      In 2012, our elections will merely allow us to pick the flavor of sauce in which we are to be cooked. Regardless of the electoral outcome, we are going to be cooked.