Real Reason Gold Jumped: “Because!”

Gold quotes lurched sharply higher yesterday, and we take it as especially bullish that the news media tripped over their own feet trying to explain why.  Reuters reported that prices surged because of “safe-haven demand due to ongoing fears about euro zone credit contagion.” How’s that for  lame analysis?  The Wall Street Journal didn’t do much better:  “Gold made a sudden, sharp move higher, a jump many attributed to  fears of Europe’s sovereign debt crisis.” Shouldn’t someone point out to these guys that the euro held its own yesterday for a rare change and that that is surely an odd way for traders to have expressed their supposed anxiety over Europe’s financial fate? Another talking head who apparently didn’t get it was Bart Melek, a global commodity strategist for some firm: “It’s a bizarre move,” Melek told the Journal. “Fundamentally,” he said, “we really have not seen many things today” that could justify such a big jump.

Lest Melek and the others lose sleep over bullion’s vexatious vault, we’ll spell it out for them in just one word:  B-E-C-A-U-S-E!  “Because why?” Melek might ask. Just because, we’d reply, leaving it at that. Sometimes explanations need be no more complicated than that, and this is one of those times.  And anyway, anyone who still wonders why gold has taken a big leap on a given day must have been living on Mars while the yellow metal’s price quintupled from $250 to $1250 over the last ten years. They are the very same geniuses who have no difficulty explaining each and every 200-point rally in the Dow:  “The strength of the economic recovery is what did it,”  they will tell you – and never mind the fact that it is the banking sector alone that has felt any real improvement.

Brace for Worse

We’d suggest that the pundits brace for a washout decline in stocks in the days and weeks ahead, as Europe pretends to deal with a grave financial crisis that has now come to include a run on Hungary’s debt and currency. Nor should anyone be surprised if Gold’s share of safe-haven money continues to rise, as it absolutely should if there’s a vestige of sanity left in the investment world. Over the near term, our specific target for Gold, basis the August Comex contract, is 1261.80, although a close above that number would make 1293.50 an odds-on bet.  Yesterday, we’d thought gold might remain in a lazy drift or perhaps even go lower this week, but after yesterday’s buzz-saw performance, it looks like bulls will be proceeding without trepidation. If you’re interested in a detailed daily analysis of gold but don’t subscribe, consider taking a free week’s trial to Rick’s Picks by clicking here.

(If you’d like to have Rick’s Picks commentary delivered free each day to your e-mail box, click here.)

  • Richard June 12, 2010, 4:32 pm

    Wow! For some ‘fiat’ currency is real money?? Who said faith based religions are a dying breed? Ok, we’ll just make sure there is less of this ‘monopoly’ money available than Milton Bradley produces, raise interest rates, default on everything and all will be well? I am real sure that this does not enhance productivity, but will increase product scarcity, therefore fewer dollars chasing fewer products. Prices then go where? Recycling/Bartering/home gardens will of course be big.

    It is important to note that, for the moment, the US Dollar is somehow the best toilet paper around, but we all know what happens to even the the best of this stuff. Another thought. What’s the big lather about the value of gold?? At its current price, the US of A has only enough of it to pay off the Greece mess or barely enough to cover its own defict for just Janaury, i.e.; about $ 300 biliion. In addition, the rest of the world’s Government gold reserves can’t poke a real hole in any sovereign debt crisis. Gold appears to have no real economic solution capabilities/ ‘ju-ju’ for the moment when it is just $ 1225.

    History will repeat itself regarding ‘fiat’ and the light-of-day will make it clear to all. Hang on, the ride will be wild.

  • ben June 9, 2010, 10:14 am

    Are thos actually CRT monitors in that picture above? Wow…the news media really is hurting…I threw away a dozen working CRT monitors a few years ago after unsuccessfully trying to give them away.

    On another note…anyone see the article about bin Laden hiding in Iran for the past five years? I always suspected he was there after seeing the widely disseminated reports a few years back that his terrorist son was living in Iran.

    http://www.debka.com/article/8841/

  • JohnJay June 8, 2010, 9:47 pm

    Simple reason why gold is going up.
    Our civilization is collapsing.
    The corporations are busy looting whatever they can.
    Government workers are thrashing about trying to preserve their privileged lifestyle.
    We are surrounded by frauds, charlatans, and rogues.

  • fallingman June 8, 2010, 7:51 pm

    Gold craze? I suppose it was a craze at $350 and $500 too. What’s this about … traders concerning themselves with Thomian notions of “fair” value? This ain’t the middle ages, guys.

    Prechter? Nice, intelligent, interesting, insightful guy … who has been so wrong about gold for so long you could have lost a half-dozen fortunes by now following his advice.

    “Because” … exactly. Thank you Rick.

  • Robert June 8, 2010, 7:47 pm

    @ Gary Leibowitz:

    “The safe haven argument when the world falls into a deflation spiral has not been tested yet so the results are unknown. Without a gold standard I can’t see it as a great investment.”

    -Umm, the fact that gold is at or near record highs in all global currencies suggests to me that there IS a Gold Standard… perhaps not as a matter of policy, but c’mon- I’ve already laid out the value of a government promise (which is all that a US Dollar really is)

    And it HAS been tested- the 1930’s set a prime example. It wasn’t the Gold Standard- it was Gold AS the standard.

    I’m stymied by how many of you have fallen for the ruse that somehow government policy over the past 70 years has magically “converted” gold from money into just another commodity that has no inherent value save dangling from the ears of your botox injected, fake boobed, trophy bimbo…

    Mises said that all valid forms of money must maintain scarcity to preserve purchasing power.

    Perhaps it is global drug dealers that are converting their cash hoardes into Gold….? There is enough global cash under the table in illegal drug cartel posession to easily take the Gold market to places that none of you deflationists would readily imagine…

    Speaking of- How are the prices of Pot and Cocaine going to hold up as deflation sets in?

    Gold- the money laundering vehicle of the 21st century?

    🙂

    &&&&&&

    Cupla terrific posts, Robert! Thanks. RA

    • Rich June 9, 2010, 6:33 pm

      Leave my botox injected, fake boobed, trophy bimbo out of this;
      Time will tell if gold is done for another 20 years or not.
      Meanwhile Trailing Buy and Sell Stops make dollars and sense…

  • DG June 8, 2010, 7:26 pm

    It seems healthy that the debate rages here on the worthiness of gold.
    The top is not on the horizon, IMWO (worthless).
    It seems a little obvious though, that all fiat currencies, which once were measured in gold, and now are not, will vaporize over time. This is a certainty. It is not like this is hyperbole, there are decades, if not centuries of data to illustrate this. The demands on the poor dollar (or euro) are just too much. The politicians have loaded so much onto the buck that it will be impossible to survive. The deficit and public debt is but a pimple. It is insane. Suggesting that BS Bernanke lives up to his helicopter name is not much of a speculation, given what he has already done (and said will do). That is as silly as thinking Obama was possibly going to have a left leaning agenda. ya think!?
    Netscape went public (and it was an insane offering) in August of 1995, a full four years before the manic, jaw dropping, “I don’t freakin’ believe it” top. When they went out in ’95 there were plenty who were screaming, “well that is it. You’ll never see that again.” right
    The gold warm up band hasn’t even been announced. We are at June of 1972. (that Summer, by the way, defied all seasonalities…)
    Metals are going up because fewer people want to sell it than own it. Who knows? Maybe this is where the bankers are stashing their politically bribed bonuses. It beats the hell out of owning their banks which are still sitting on loans for homes which folks regret ever buying. That truth will be revealed.

    • Rich June 9, 2010, 6:30 pm

      From June 1972 to 1980 was less than a decade for gold to top and drop.

      As Rick noted, gold quintupled from 2000 to 2010.

      It may be overdue for a shellacking.

      Franz Pick was right over the long term that bonds are certificates of confiscation and the destiny of currencies is to die.

      In the interim things can get pretty interesting, even wild, with debt default deflation…

  • Steve June 8, 2010, 6:40 pm

    Here is what Robert Prechter says about gold falling 40%. “Asked if Prechter still expected gold to correct 40 percent, he said that extremes in technical indicators still “leave gold vulnerable to that large of a decline.” The link is here..http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE65652L20100607

  • david June 8, 2010, 4:45 pm

    You all make it so complicated and Rick is trying to justify his big miss on gold with his pivot.There are times in the business,economic and geopolitical cycle where certain assets can’t help but perform….For such a time as this gold stands out.Inflation deflation BS its capital waves of incredible proportions that are voting that paper money with no reasonable way of being repaid in debt servicing and a long time of manipulation and price suppression is coming to an end.The banks are losing control and the government puppets as well.Money is just a tool and you want it stable.Paper money world wide is at a crisis point and confidence is eroding.Because of the speed of info dissemination people ,institutions, pension funds insurance co.’s etc. have only a few safety spots gold, real estate or other hard assets.Don’t get cute trying to play gold you will get crushed.Its money now not deflation or inflation who cares if Rick is right and its deflation but money isnt circulating than why is gold going up regardless of neg. interest rates.Buy and hold and when your waiter and shoe salesmen suggest buying then think of a bubble!

    &&&&&

    You’re welcome to pore over my archive any time to see how many “big misses” I’ve had in Gold over the last ten years versus thousands of “hits,” many of them bullseyes, in all time frames. You should also read the last couple forecasts, one of which you have evidently miscategorized as a “big miss.” That said, I agree with your conclusions about gold’s strength. RA

  • mario cavolo June 8, 2010, 4:06 pm

    Another reason we’re going to hell BECAUSE:

    ” The watchdogs have abandoned their posts….As daily newspapers continue to shed Washington bureaus and severely slash their staffs, fewer reporters than ever are serving as watchdogs of the federal government. Rare is the reporter who is assigned to cover one of the many federal departments, agencies or bureaus that are not part of the daily news cycle. Even if they are large, even if they are central to how Americans live their lives, most parts of the federal government–the very offices that write the rules and execute the decisions of Congress and the president–remain uncovered or undercovered by the mainstream media. ”

    Another piece in the puzzle of how the elite and govt have put up a wall isolating themselves from the citizenry. Link below to the rest of the must read article…insightful and well-written.

    http://www.ajr.org/Article.asp?id=4877

    Cheers, Mario

    • Benjamin June 8, 2010, 5:59 pm

      I would say it’s an indication that we are going to hell, not a reason.

      It is time-consuming to review an agency and what goes on inside, but that is the cost of malinvestment in Big Government in the first place. So naturally, it’s going to stretch resource to the breaking point, just as it does on the private sector as a whole. Private sector employ is way down, while government is in an unbearably steady trend. Which is to say that covering agencies is in itself a moot point (though a red-alert none the less). The agencies themselves must go, along with the over-extended powers, employment, and payrolls that they have at their disposal.

      And lo, the agencies complain of being under-staffed. No big surprise there. I mean, look at other areas of the government sector, where manpower and compensation are disproportionately higher.

      Turns out that there’s a price tag in trying to fool most of the people most of the time, and one I say that can’t possibly be paid except through the self-destruction of the whole behemoth.

  • Tom Paine June 8, 2010, 2:24 pm

    Ron,

    I think gold buyers are anticipating the policy response of debasement of fiat currencies which has become the norm for dealing with credit crises.

    • Rich June 9, 2010, 6:23 pm

      When something becomes a norm, it fades…

  • Ron Carver June 8, 2010, 2:06 pm

    I have a question which has been vexing me. I fully understand the logic behind the deflation argument: money supply crashes as old loans are repaid but no new loans made, default of old loans makes it harder for banks to loan out more money. ‘Net result, less money out there to buy “stuff”. Inevitably, the price of “stuff” must then decline. This is pretty simple really.
    But why would gold be any different. If there’s less money around chasing goods and services, wouldn’t you expect gold’s price to also drop, for exactly the same reasons? Thanks.

    • Rich June 8, 2010, 2:57 pm

      Well said Ron.
      Gold IS no different from other markets, except for those who worship it.
      There is no US government gold monetary standard since 1933 and 1971 to hold up gold miner profits, and Uncle Sam is facing insolvency from increasing expenditures, borrowing and falling tax revenues from 22% unemployment. (A remnant went to the Wall Street Casino to try to make ends meet.)
      Those betting on gold here with a new 1254.50 intraday high are betting Helicopter Ben lives up to his name.
      Right now the point and figure trend target for gold is 1310 and gold is banging on a possible double top.
      GoldCorp and other LDC mines were repossessed.
      It will be interesting and dirty if Iran explodes the nuclear weapon arsenal Israel never admitted having.
      Gold is such a small global market, $6 Trillion, relative to the $600 trillion in derivatives, that any liquidity going that way can squeeze it hard for a while.
      So why have experienced Central Banks except ChIndia been selling the stuff?
      The answer may be the -90% collapse in the annual rate of monetary base growth in Anglo America, combined with a money multiplier far less than 1.
      We are looking for one explosive last hurrah in euroyen, gold, commodities and stocks before the giant deflationary market douche. It could start today and even run to new highs. Gentlemen start your engines…

    • gary leibowitz June 8, 2010, 3:12 pm

      Good point. I believe your scenario will play out when deflation is seen as a major problem. Until then money will chase the gold craze. It will be interesting to see what happens when we have another sharp crash in equities. So far every large drop has resulted in gold falling also. How many weak hands are there chasing the metal?

      The safe haven argument when the world falls into a deflation spiral has not been tested yet so the results are unknown. Without a gold standard I can’t see it as a great investment.

    • Benjamin June 8, 2010, 4:28 pm

      @All three, again…

      Gold rose because gold is no ones promise to repay.

      This alone is not enough to explain things, however. After all, neither is copper anyones liability. But gold is also limited in supply. But so are houses. So what it comes down to is gold’s stocks to flow, that is how easily above-ground supply is disrupted by new supply from the ground. So…

      Gold is not a liability to someone else. There is only so much of it and new supply is relatively hard to come by, which makes it stable and thus too valuable to deflate like other asset classes. Yes, it can crash like it did in ’08, but it didn’t go as low percentwise as everything else did. As I said yesterday, it can go all the way back to 800s (maybe even lower) without ruining the overall picture.

    • Robert June 8, 2010, 7:33 pm

      “But why would gold be any different. If there’s less money around chasing goods and services, wouldn’t you expect gold’s price to also drop, for exactly the same reasons? ”

      Ask yourself the following question:

      As of right now, today, June 8, 2010- where are my capital savings the safest?

      1) Bonds- prices at all time highs, and yields that will likely not maintain parity with the price of grains going forward.

      2) USDollars stuffed in the mattress- a good bet if your only worry is who will be left as the last man standing in the global fiat currency death-match

      3) A substance that is convertible to any currency at any time, and is presently priced at record highs in all currencies?

      The money supply is falling as rapidly as it did in 1930. The difference?- in 1930 money was BACKED by something other than government promises.

      WHAT DOES A GOVERNMENT PROMISE PURCHASE TODAY…?

      WHAT WILL A GOVERNMENT PROMISE PURCHASE TOMORROW…?

      Duh?

      All of you who belive that the gold price will suffer in an impending deflation seemingly do not understand the difference between money and credit. USDollars are NOT subject to basic supply-demand economic theory, because the potential supply of USDollars is as infinite as the supply of hydrogen in the Universe. Dollars do NOT increase in value in a deflationary environment. Only the value of REAL MONEY increases during deflation. All deflation will do for the dollar is embolden the Central Bankers to print even more.

      Or, do you all REALLY beleive that the day will come when the Central Bankers will shut down their liquidity swap windows and turn off the printing presses?

      Seriously, do any of you beleive that?

      Also- the worst deflation in history lasted from 1931 to 1937- what did the price of Gold do during that time?

      People choose to PROTECT their savings during times of uncertainty- the last place I would invest my money in the current environment is in hydrogen.

    • Rich June 9, 2010, 6:22 pm

      “Dollars do NOT increase in value in a deflationary environment.” ???

      Look at scarce dollars and their buying power during the Great Depression, or the dollar at 70.70 in March 2008 versus 88.39 today.

      The dollar is 25% higher vs gold 21% higher, a 20% advantage dollar.

      A dollar today buys a lot more real estate and stocks than it did in 2007.

      Still waiting for acknowledgement or refutation of the contractionary 82.5% money multiplier or the monetary base annual rate of change down -90%, two charts ignored by gold bugs at their peril perhaps…

      http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/MULT

      http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/?chart_type=line&s%5B1%5D%5Bid%5D=BASE&s%5B1%5D%5Btransformation%5D=pc1

  • Benjamin June 8, 2010, 1:44 pm

    Gold rose because gold is no one’s promise to repay. There is no other reason. No other reason is even needed!

  • Richard Dudley June 8, 2010, 1:08 pm

    Gold has been following the seasonal to the day day with pin-point accuracy. Gold will sell off hard today into June 20-21, although up 10 bucks at 1250 with a high of 1254 at 7:04 AM EST

  • mario cavolo June 8, 2010, 8:58 am

    ….all good things gentlemen and ladies…Hi Jerrold…traditionally commodities usually lead the decline…?…not follow it, and this time around as last time around, decline lead by commodities and also lead by Asia which started several months earlier….Cheers, Mario

  • Jerrold Minyard June 8, 2010, 6:50 am

    I expect gold to get slammed. I expect the stockmarket to have a big sell off. The commodities will follow.

  • FranSix June 8, 2010, 6:04 am

    I would be watching declines in short term yields for any pointer to the direction of gold prices lately. But Bloomberg has decided to remodel their website, so a good source of free data on short term yields the world over has disappeared.

  • TahoeBilly June 8, 2010, 6:03 am

    Now here are some sanctions that make sense…Russia tells Iran “if you do anything to start a conflict with Israel, we are cutting you off, completely, no mas, you’re done” and conversely the US says to Israel “if you do anything to start a conflict with Iran, we are cutting you off, completely, no mas, your done”.

    This is the way the world should work, does anyone give a rats ass about religious “freak” countries who want to blow each other up? When we have our own god damn problems! I’d rather back the MOONIES in an airport lounge than Rome, Tel Aviv or Tehran…FREAK SHOWS!!

  • mark June 8, 2010, 5:10 am

    surprises are to the upside in bull markets

    &&&&&

    Bull markets? RA

    • mark June 8, 2010, 12:06 pm

      RA,i was not suggesting that there are more than 1 bull market at the moment.
      simply stating that inside of a bull market,”surprises” are to the upside

  • keith June 8, 2010, 4:34 am

    Let me tell you something right now. You are the most right person I’ve met all week. I’ve seen days where gold should have went up but instead went down like a lead balloon. Which if you are a Led Zeppelin fan you’ll know the name came from the fact that “they” thought it was going to do down like a lead balloon. And so we have gold. Get the picture?

  • PhotoRadarScam June 8, 2010, 3:20 am

    The point is well taken about the lack of explanations. It’s often comical the reasons they come up with to justify a move either way for a given index or commodity – most of the time they are grasping at straws… or headlines.

    IMO, if the move today was caused by anything it was caused by Iran’s announcement that they plan to deploy their revolutionary guard to escort ships through the Israeli blockade. This is a recipe for trouble, because I don’t see either side backing down.

    • Jerrold Minyard June 8, 2010, 6:53 am

      That is great observation, about Iran’s announcement. Powder keg. This could make the metal move higher. I’m short on them though.

    • Max Power June 8, 2010, 4:43 pm

      I thought it might be because of Iran moving out of Euros and dollars and into gold…