Some Days, Everyone Simply Gets It Wrong

Let’s see if we understand yesterday’s earth-rumbling response to China’s 25 basis-point increase in a yuan lending rate. For starters, the dollar had its biggest one-day rally since August (which, to remind you, went nowhere; the dollar wafted slightly higher, then scuddled sideways for nearly a month before resuming its long-term bear market). Another effect of China’s decidedly un-momentous change, which supposedly was aimed at damping real estate speculation and inflation, was that bullion had its worst day in recent memory.  Comex Gold and Silver futures contracts were down nearly three percent, and there was little evidence at the bell that bullion’s inevitable rebound was immediately imminent. And, finally, we saw the heaviest selling of equity shares in more than two months, with the Dow Industrials down 226 points at their intraday lows.

Does all of this mean anything?  In a word, no. China’s modest rate hike did not change any global paradigms, and gold and silver most assuredly are not anticipating a shift toward austerity by those drunken sailors of our economic lives, the central banks.  As for the dollar, there was talk that its big rally represented the flight of capital into the safe haven of cash.  But if  that is so, why did that other treacherously overrated “safe haven” – i.e., U.S. Treasury bonds – not come along for the ride?  December T-Bond futures were in fact up a whopping nine ticks, reflecting no appreciable surge in fear, nor any increase in the demand for “safety,” even when attached to a nominal yield.

 Shouldn’t the Dollar Have Fallen?

One is tempted to say the whole investment world got it wrong yesterday, and that the dollar should logically have fallen on news of an increase in Chinese lending rates.  That the greenback moved the “wrong” way is akin to the wild conniptions that Treasury bonds trace out whenever some wholly fabricated, miserably worthless statistic like the payroll number hits the tape. Usually, the initial price stab is reflexively opposite whatever mini-trend existed moments prior to the announcement, and it typically takes two or three more wild counter-swings to orient the bonds in a direction that can somehow be rationalized as logical, based on the news. And so it was yesterday with the dollar, except that, instead of “getting square” with the news by day’s end, it will instead experience second and third thoughts in the days ahead. A delayed reaction, in other words. And because nearly all dollar hedges these days are carry trades built on short-dollar strategies, we shouldn’t be too surprised if the short-squeezy swings continue to be pretty wild.

Meanwhile, what helped to greatly exaggerate price movement in numerous markets yesterday is the fact that “something” – in this case a hitherto obscure and inconsequential Chinese lending rate — had changed. Traders seized upon this news-from-out-of-the-blue with the headless-chicken demeanor that gives the markets their entertainment value.  With China making it more costly to borrow the yuan, the traders must have asked themselves, Shouldn’t we react to this – and react in a BIG way, since we haven’t heard news of this sort in who-knows-how-long?  And so, they reacted – wildly. Shamelessly.  Idiotically. But we should not allow yesterday’s mindless spasms to taint or even color our thoughts on gold and silver, which remain in a powerful, long-term bull market; or on the dollar, which at this point is capable only of an occasional death rattle as it settles into its grave.

(If you’d like to have Rick’s Picks commentary delivered free each day to your e-mail box, click here.)

  • gary leibowitz October 20, 2010, 9:26 pm

    The dancing partners, gold and equites, have been at it for a long time. Why would supposed bad news for equities rattle gold?

    If gold is a true hedge then why is it square dancing as partners?

    When will we see gold’s “true colors”? Perhaps we are.

  • FranSix October 20, 2010, 4:58 pm

    The entire market could be one big failure to deliver. If we are to have another flash crash, then anything which may have performed in the previous flash crash would appear to be a layup for a rally.

    • ben October 20, 2010, 7:03 pm

      All this talk of flash crashes…we could also have a “flash rally.” In fact, with all the effort being putting in to prevent another crash I think a flash rally is the more likely scenario.

  • PhotoRadarScam October 20, 2010, 7:49 am

    This is just more evidence that the charts do what they do, and the media spinsters struggle to attach some event – in most cases a coincidence – to explain what happens naturally. Quite simply the markets were overstretched and were due for a correction.

    One other theory I have is that when a currency such as the yuan is tied to the USD, the USD is thus tied to the yuan. In most cases the currencies are weak (such as the Iraqi dinar) and have no effect on the USD, but the yuan is NOT weak, and as such, with a fixed exchange rate to the USD it can actually prop up the dollar…

    • Robert October 20, 2010, 5:31 pm

      I have to agree with PRS. I can’t see the direct correlation between yesterdays action and the Chinese rate hike. I can see how the Chinese news would influence certain moves, but not a broad, multi sector selloff… I think yesterday was simply a lot of profit taking and some orchestrated stop triggering…

      As Freud said so eloquently; “sometimes a cigar is just a cigar”

  • Edward October 20, 2010, 5:32 am

    Bigger news from China was their decision to embargo the US on strategic material. Take a look at the action in res.v.
    And now let me share my forecast for shares. The market will continue down into approximately the 1125 area. It should find legs there, and make a final run into the first week or so of November. If 1125 doesn’t hold within a few points, I expect the final move into early November to have difficulty exceeding Monday’s high.

    • ricecake October 20, 2010, 8:00 am

      China has 30% of the world rare earth reserve but export 90% of the world’s rare earth. The US has lots of rare earth resource too but the Americans close all their mines for “environmental concerns.” Instead the Americans are importing using up the Chinese reserve first and in dirt cheap prices too! Beside the Americans, the Japanese import lots of the rare earth like there’s no tomorrow from China for more than 20 years and store their imported stock in their secret warehouse under ocean. The stock is enough for another 50 years use.

      Now the Chinese wake up and discover that they are such bunch dumb arses. Not only they sell their Rare Earth like cabbage, they also realize that their remaining reserve of the rare earth is only enough for another 20 years. So it’s very reasonable for them to protect what’s left and close up their remaining reserve not for mining for a long long time because of the “environmental concern.” Rare Earth is very poisonous.

      Time for the US to re-open American’s rare earth mine again.

    • Robert October 20, 2010, 5:21 pm

      Good point Edward-

      Funny how China announces no Silver exports to the West, and no more Rare Earth exports, yet the stocks of the western mining companies get kicked in the throat… Anyone who sees this as more than a near term stop triggering smack down isn’t doing enough homework.

      I got some great deals yesterday- XRA at 5.56, and sold January 23 puts on SLW for a buck a share.

  • TC October 20, 2010, 4:34 am

    Nice call on Apple Rick. Im curious to see where you think it is going next.