Cheap-o Greek Bailout Is Not Calming Markets

Bruised and bloodied bears must have felt a rare sense of exhilaration yesterday as trading on the NYSE drew to a close. That, and a twinge of anxiety about whether U.S. stocks could actually fall for two days running. Some traders evidently decided not to bet on it, and so short-covering drove the best rally of the day in the final half-hour.  After all, who would have had the guts to take a short position overnight in a market that has been on a wilding spree for 14 months?  Some short-covering is bound to occur at the tail end of any day on which the Dow has fallen more than 200 points, as it did yesterday. But the fact there wasn’t more of it, and that the lows penetrated some key supports identified in yesterday’s commentary, suggests there is more selling to come.  Bear in mind that Tuesday is a dangerous time of the week for an all-day selloff to occur, since it leaves three days for the selling to mutate into panic.

The ostensible reason for yesterday’s decline, which saw the Dow down nearly 300 points at its lows, was news of fresh trouble in euroland. But decide for yourself whether this is really news:  “Global markets tumbled as investors questioned the viability of plans to bail out Greece and fretted about knock-on effects in other nations.” That’s how the Wall Street Journal saw it, but the story is getting to be so “dog-bites-man” that its impact on the markets is probably overrated at this point. Make no mistake, an historical day of reckoning awaits euroland and its politically fraught currency when Greece’s fatal debt disease is suddenly discovered to infect all of Europe. But for the moment, we can only stifle a yawn when we read on one day about how such and such sum of money has been advanced Greece; and on the next, about how this sum is feared to be inadequate.

A Global Blood Supply

As we already know from the U.S. real estate/bank meltdown, it takes a good trillion dollars or so of supposed bailing out to delude the masses into thinking, if but for a brief moment, that the “system” has been “saved.” Since everyone understands that Greece’s financial problems are not Greece’s alone, and that Spain and the other PIGS are next, it is absolutely dumbfounding that the rescuers have tried to conjure up a bailout of Athens on-the-cheap. Could they have learned nothing from watching Bear Stearns’ difficulties metastasize until they almost took down the entire U.S. banking system?  Some might say this is comparing apples to oranges and that the problems of banks are different from those of sovereign entities.  We see the two entities as not merely joined at the hip, but as sharing the same heart, brain and blood supply. Too big too fail no longer means big banks, but rather the entire global financial system.  Fallout from a Greek bankruptcy will be felt initially in Brussels, Frankfurt, Paris and London, but eventually – though perhaps not long afterward — in Topeka, Auckland, and Cape Town.  Will you be ready if, say, your bank were to limit daily withdrawals to $200? That might be as good as it gets when the dominoes start to fall.

(If you’d like to have Rick’s Picks commentary delivered free each day to your e-mail box, click here.)

Comments on this entry are closed.

  • Oliver May 6, 2010 @ 7:42

    This comment I´d like to add, then I´ll be quiet again: there is a writer at the NYT, Landon Thomas Jr., who describes a scenario for Europe, which I think is how the assessment generally runs faulty.
    That described reallocation of paper assets towards Frankfurt in a confidence crisis can be stopped in Europe twofold: any money in Europe has an implied passport attached to it.
    The real paper money has alphabet signatures from which country it´s coming and, second and very important, all electronic or otherwise non-tangible assets are coming with a trail signature of origin. Like, if you have money market stuff in Frankfurt and that comes from a greek account, bearing a greek passport so to speak it ought to be possible in my opinion to just send it back.
    Runs from people from inside Europe towards Frankfurt can be stopped cold, if I´m not wrong.
    They would have to run for gold etc and dollar. And get out of Europe.
    That´s not for everybody.

    Right?

  • John May 6, 2010 @ 5:12

    Rick wrote, “Will you be ready if, say, your bank were to limit daily withdrawals to $200?”

    No problem. I convert 1000s of checking account dollars to physical dollar coins. Cheap, easy, quick from the US Mint.
    http://catalog.usmint.gov/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/CategoryDisplay?langId=-1&storeId=10001&catalogId=10001&identifier=8100

    This gets me physical dollars that aren’t those nasty federal reserve notes.

  • JohnJay May 5, 2010 @ 20:02

    The US economy may be picking up for the “Haves”, but the “Have-Nots” are not doing to well in the land of the left behinds. I saw a presentation on the local PBS TV station of high school kids in Pomona, CA telling about the financial straits their families are in. It was pititful even to this old cynic to see those young kids break down on camera talking about parents losing jobs and being way behind on rent or the mortgage. Even old man Rockefeller passed out dimes, and Carnegie built libraries for the proles. These GS/JPM/Hedge Fund bastards really are disconnected from their fellow citizens like nothing I’ve ever seen.

  • Oliver May 5, 2010 @ 18:16

    🙂
    Chris T.: Sorry, that I blew my top. 🙁
    But I also think we ought to stand together more, the western, industrialized, democratic citizens.
    I get the goose pimples, if I look at China´s rising influence on the US via debt.
    In Europe, communism keeps coming back, ever more intricate in it´s arduous, faulted arguments – luring more and more.
    I´m more afraid, than anything.
    Some in Europe, way too many, argue in ways hopelessly lost in socialist space.
    Maybe my scenario is wishful thinking as I don´t know how many voters are actually already tied to the state (way to many).
    But should Europe make a swing into the conservative/liberal arena like in the (Reagan), Thatcher, d`Estaing, Kohl, area the scenario would actually be possible. And renew Europe in a feel good way.
    White Swan, maybe.
    The greatest danger to this scenario is the inherent weakness of the European liberal parties as they are being wrongly associated with the banking ponzi mentality.
    Here, free markets are being blamed for the problem, nobody realizing it´s the governments with no fiscal discipline, buying votes, that cause all this.
    A great lack in Europe is the average citizens understanding of the economy and markets as a whole. Schools have verily failed here.
    The only parties saying this out loud now are the liberal parties. Ok, Dr. Merkel´s speech today actually contained everything needed: regulated default, suspension of voting right (!) and suspension of economic aid (!!) AND expulsion from the Euro-zone (!!!).
    She couldn´t say this without M. Sarkozy´s backing, I hope.
    The concept of having debt-sinners pay a fine, enlarging their debt pile, was… well, not intelligent, to say it nicely.

  • Chris T. May 5, 2010 @ 16:32

    Just because Greece is part of a currency (system), doesn’t have to mean it couldn’t go into default without endangering the whole system.
    If California or NJ were to do this (they should), would the dollar fall apart?
    Greece did enjoy by far too little risk assessed against it by the market, because they were in the Euro.
    Unless the “will be bailed out” assessment was part of this, ie the moral-hazard like we see stateside.

    After all, no one cares about bailing out Greece per se, and this is not Greece’s problem. They have already spent the money.
    It is the creditors’ problem, they are the ones being bailed out, and are the well-connected entities.
    .
    Greece is the AIG in this case.
    If all this debt’s creditors were domestic entities, the bailout would not be an issue.

    Once again, the taxpayer, Europe’s in this case, will have to bail out private interests for lending out money to a subprime borrower.
    Consider that French banks hold almost 800 billion of Italy’s debt alone, and one can see why the governments are bailing them out.

    So, if the Euro collapses, it won’t be because Greece is let to fail, but because it is not forced to liquidate. This ever relocating of debt to the next higher entity will eventually have to lead to Mises’ crack-up, and its final outcome.

    And I think Mises will be shown to have been right, versus the “we can do this in perpetuity because governments are different” comment from the other day.

    Aside: while Oliver’s comment the other day was prob. not meant in a triumphalist way, the things he points out being better in Europe/Germany, are so not BECAUSE OF, but DESPITE those countries’ governments policies, and thanks for that. How long can that last if these policies remain, who knows?

  • Rich May 5, 2010 @ 16:01

    Aloha All
    We continue with strong solar sunspot X Rays and geomagnetic fields that in the past correlated with market volatility.
    After two recent greater than 90% down volume days, we are due for a respite rally. If we don’t get one by Friday, that may be ominous indeed.
    CZI may be targeting 44, and the geometric compounding of triple leverage combined with daily resets may lead to reverse splits and capital loss, but the indices tracked by CZI and FZP are ADRs, and the China 25 respectively. Per MC, these US Chinese stocks/indices lagged the Shanghai Composite since last August, when it peaked.
    http://stockcharts.com/charts/gallery.html?$SSEC
    These are interesting times, with talking heads still promoting buying dips. We would rather sell any strength after running into the top of the 80-year Dow trend.
    http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_TwUS3GyHKsQ/S7VH1QeuaZI/AAAAAAAAEpo/kL2-TVUo8jI/s1600/2010-04-01-PROPHET.png
    Cash is certainly cool.
    Regards*Rich

  • gary leibowitz May 5, 2010 @ 15:03

    Interesting how, for the time being, we are showing signs of economic growth while the rest of the world is just getting caught up in their own debt imbalance. A perfect storm is developing in the U.S. where growth starts picking up after the earnings surge.

    I suspect you might be right when your analysis suggests another possible spike of 10 percent or more.
    If this latest round of volatile market moves settles and bases near 1150 without breaking we could see a final (?) rally.

  • Oliver May 5, 2010 @ 7:35

    Societe General has just declared to be bullish on Spain (spanish stocks) again, now.
    They explain that with highly exaggerated sell-offs not taking into account the recovery in Latin America.
    They assess the debt structure of Spain being bearable and they expect the joblessness to retreat, now – on the Latin America recovery.
    But there seems to be trouble in German parliament about the rescue package for Greece… This might take a couple more days.
    Greatest problem in Spain seem to be the regional banks burdened with the fallout of their real estate bubble.

  • Melvill May 5, 2010 @ 4:23

    If this frigging bear market rally continues I won’t have $200 to withdraw.

  • SDavid May 5, 2010 @ 3:17

    With any luck, all these problems surfacing with the Euro will be more than enough to keep Canadians from buying into the “Amero.”

  • mario cavolo May 5, 2010 @ 2:39

    Rick, um..er..that would be me holding the shorts 🙂 and yes, I invite everyone to share that pain. But perhaps now it will play out right….more specifically the China shorts…the U.S. based China indexes have been lagging the decline in HK and Shanghai indexes that started over 2 weeks ago. They should continue tanking to hell this morning after the Tuesday dive. The Shanghai Composite has gone straight to hell from 3100 to 2700’s in the past 2 weeks. the Hang Seng chart looks ugly, I’ve been holding CZI , the 3x bear etf, a nasty bastard not to be held longer than a few days, and yesterday I added FXP the 2x bear for the FXI which finally broke key support.

    The bank tightening has sent apt buyers home. No, there will NOT be a bust, just a decline.

    …got a ridiculous but maybe not ridiculous pitch recently that oil and gold are about to surge post a special May 10th commodities related filing by the banks who are now secretly hoarding physical as part of their strategy to control the markets.

    We’ll see…Cheers, Mario

  • DN May 5, 2010 @ 2:36

    Greece should only be used as the “indicator prototype” of how their debt problems are handled by the Euro zone in general. The fact that all of the Euro zone countries are tied to the Euro is akin to being on a gold standard and thereby simple money printing is not easily feasible or possible.

    How the more viable Euro zone countries (Germany, France) cope and react to weaker ones could be the real wildcard here. One that comes to mind in particular could be Spain and when debt obligations begin to mature/roll over in the next 12 months. Funding their whopping 130% External Debt of GDP is crucial. There are few precedents under this set of circumstances:

    1) Can’t simply print
    2) 130% of external debt as % of GDP
    3) Fragmentation of EU zone
    4) Reluctance of tight fisted Germans to aid
    5) Reluctance of problem EU countries to cut back in the face of socialistic tendencies