This Is No Time to Sack a General

Will a squabble with his Afghanistan troop commander be the undoing of the Obama presidency?  And will that prove to be the straw that broke the camel’s back on Wall Street, which has been blithely buying up shares for sixteen months in the face of the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression? The Republic is already reeling from the disaster in the Gulf of Mexico; from the looming bankruptcy of scores of states and big cities; from the just-begun, second wave of the housing bust; from the mountainous juggernaut of new taxes that will be needed to pay for Government’s breathtaking expansion into healthcare and just about everything else. Add in a decisive failure in Afghanistan, and there are more problems than the November elections could conceivably resolve. It’s one thing to hope that America will toss the bums out, but we don’t envy their replacements the task they will face if the economy’s plunge is approaching terminal velocity when the new Congress is sworn in in late autumn.

General Stanley McChrystal tactfullness is not his strength

In the meantime, we won’t quibble with Mr. Obama’s decision to call Gen. McChrystal on the carpet. It was an unfathomable lapse for a military man with a crucial role in the nation’s defense to loosen up in an interview with, of all publications, The Rolling Stone.  He made the President look bad by saying Obama had seemed “uncomfortable and intimidated” at a meeting with military brass.  As plausible as this sounds, McChrystal should never have brought it up. Under the circumstances, the President has no choice but to project forcefulness in dealing with the errant general. But fire him?  The general’s war record in Iraq earned him the respect of his troops, and the last thing they need is to lose their commander because he spoke rashly. Moreover, the U.S. is in the middle of a crucial campaign in Afghanistan, building momentum for an assault on Kandahar, the Taliban stronghold. Whether you believe we should be in Afghanistan or not, there is no disputing that an American retreat would embolden the enemy.

Let’s hope the President makes the right call this time. He cannot afford any more big setbacks.

(If you’d like to have Rick’s Picks commentary delivered free each day to your e-mail box, click here.)

  • Rich June 23, 2010, 11:13 pm
  • Rich June 23, 2010, 8:41 pm

    Just watched Level II ARCA for GLD around the FOMC announcement and saw size coming in to the upside…

  • BDTR June 23, 2010, 8:05 pm

    Done, … and good riddance.

    There’s nothing less excusable nor more derelict than a commanding US general betraying executive authority. This general has betrayed his oath of duty to the service of our country.

    If he had objections to his orders on standing policy or personnel, he could voice them through channels or otherwise do the right and honourable and resign.

    Obama has exercised the only correct option in accepting his resignation. Like him, loathe him, he is President of the United States of America. A very troubled country not of his exclusive making.

    • Rich June 23, 2010, 9:15 pm

      extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice…

  • Don June 23, 2010, 7:57 pm

    I concur with Steve’s messages and most of the others here. I’m not an Army guy, ole Marine, I do support the
    General. His methodology could have been better in making his views known. Never the less we have lost a great commander who has given greatly to his country.
    In my 68 years spending 17+ of those as CEO, I have made many mistakes in my my life both professionally and personally.
    The greatest mistake I have made in my life is to have contributed, campaigned for and voted for our current straw leader and feel the betrayal he has demonstrated to our country.
    Last but not least indulging the inflammatory speech delivered by the cucaracha from our southern neighbor at the White House and not only being condoned but endorsed by our leader to defame the rule of law in the recently protective act by one of our sovereign states, Arizona. In my older view this is nothing short of insulting the peoples of this country and especially the fine people of Arizona.

  • Rich June 23, 2010, 7:34 pm
  • Rich June 23, 2010, 7:30 pm

    McChrystal out and US beat Algeria.
    Let the games begin…

  • Rich June 23, 2010, 7:27 pm

    Things could get pretty interesting around 2:15 ET…

  • david June 23, 2010, 7:24 pm

    This sadly is a smokescreen by the president as it gets the countries attentions to his horrendous performance with BP.Please note the questionable characters of his administration who could not shine the good Generals shoes.Politics @ its worst.Why isn’t the media talking about the Gov. of Illinoise trial where there is potential possibility of Rahm Emmanuel and Obama to testify.Don’t be tools for this most manipulative administration and media.

  • warren June 23, 2010, 7:13 pm

    Out on a lonely country road, a salesman’s car breaks down next to small farm. The fellow gets out, opens the hood, and is looking at the engine when he hears a voice say. “It’s the injection system”.
    The salesman bangs his head on the hood as he jumps and looks around. There is only an old horse standing on the other side of a fence that runs along the road. He goes back to trying to figure out the problem with his car. After a bit he hears the same voice say again “it’s the injection system”.
    The reaction is the same, and still there is nobody around save, the old horse. Quite shaken now, the fellow decides to keep an eye on the horse while he is still trying to figure out his car’s problem. Sure enough, after a while, the horse says “it’s the injection system”.
    This freaks the guy out and he runs down the road to a farmhouse and madly bangs on the door until an old lady answers. She says “what’s all the commotion”, while looking at a very frightened young man.
    “D d d did you know that the horse down the road could talk”, he said.
    “No kidding?” she says, “what did he say?”
    “When my car broke down, he said it was the injection system”.
    “Oh well, there ya go”, says the old lady, “don’t listen to anything that old nag says, he don’t know crap about cars”.

    Just thought you guys might need a different perspective. Bye W

  • Mike Eck June 23, 2010, 5:54 pm

    I, too, had family and friends who fought in “wars for freedom.” I use quotes because I’m hard pressed to find any hint of freedom coming from any war since the revolution…quite the opposite for all conflicts in my lifetime.

    “War is just a racket. A racket is best described, I believe, as something that is not what it seems to
    be to the majority of people. Only a small inside group knows what it is about. It is conducted for
    the benefit of the very few at the expense of the masses. I believe in an adequate defense at the
    coastline and nothing else. If a nation comes over here to fight, then we’ll fight…I wouldn’t go to
    war again as I have done to protect some lousy investment of the bankers. There are only two
    things we should fight for. One is the defense of our homes and the other is the Bill of Rights. War
    for any other reason is simply a racket,” Gen. Smedley Butler, USMC, 1933, a two-time Medal of
    Honor winner. General Butler was right…it is time to stop believing everything (anything?) coming from MSM and their paying sources, governments and corporations.

    Is the BP nightmare coincidence, luck, or criminals in action? If you still believe the government fantasies about 9/11 and want to believe the lamestream media spin regarding the gulf disaster, you might want to approach this gingerly. OPERATION GULF GREASE – http://www.newswithviews.com/Weeks/darren111.htm

    Mike

    • Rich June 23, 2010, 9:14 pm

      Must read eyeopener link Mike, thanks.
      SB denied deserved promotion to Marine Commandant as too outspoken, supported WWI DC Vet Bonus Marchers before Hoover and MacArthur gassed and killed them with tanks like Waco, exposed a Corporate Fascist Business Plot to remove FDR from office ridiculed by media, correctly predicted US Pacific naval exercises meant war with Japan, and exposed the war racket on a speaking tour at his own expense covered by Reader’s Digest:
      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_Is_a_Racket

  • DAN June 23, 2010, 3:46 pm

    Richard Holbrooke is the man calling the shots and if you want to win then with rh in charge we will have the same game plan as with our win in Vietnam.

    Check out his background , he is still there from the Kissinger days

    The State Dept is a den of evil and these are the people that run our government, all unelected.

    marching orders are from State, UN, cfr. READ UP

  • Darren June 23, 2010, 3:44 pm

    Let’s hope this is McChrystal’s way of getting himself out of the Af/Pak quagmire. He would, at least, seem to have more principles than Westmoreland did.

    The US should abandon it’s entire overseas empire, including Afghanistan & Iraq. This would not be defeat or emboldening an enemy. It would simply be living in peace with the world.

    No empire is also a good way to start chipping away at the govt’s power here at home. I’m tired of these jackbooted thugs. The US govt is the threat to us, not some boneheads on the other side of the world. It (The US govt) is here, now oppressing us everyday.

    &&&&&

    Do not be so naive as to think that the world (i.e., a billion Muslims) wants to live in peace with us. In plain fact, Islamic fanatics and, yes, even moderates, want us ALL either to live under sharia or to be dead. RA

    • Darren June 24, 2010, 5:20 pm

      Christians aren’t such nice people either, you know:

      Oh, Come, All Ye Hateful

      There is an increasingly vocal and aggressive direction being taken by some Christians. That many American Christians supported the Bush administration and its wars is well known. At present the level of dehumanization of Muslims and outright advocacy of genocide is becoming much louder.
      (snip)
      http://theinternationallibertarian.blogspot.com/2010/06/oh-come-all-ye-hateful.html

      “We should invade their countries, kill their leaders and convert them to Christianity.” –Ann Coulter

      Once again you’re ignoring the 800 pound gorilla in the room. It is Uncle Sam that is oppressing us not a gang of lunatics 10,000 miles away.

      Muslims are human too & will respond to us being peaceful towards them like anyone else does. The US, & before that the Europeans, started meddling in their end of the world long before they tried attacking us over here.

      &&&&&&

      Oh, c’mon, Darren. You’re pulling our leg, right? RA

  • Steve June 23, 2010, 3:40 pm

    After reading the Great writing put forth by Rick, and reading the above comments, and making a few myself. I called the congressional delegation for this district:

    From Congress this morning- “It is inappropriate – regardless if it is truth.”

    KILL THE MESSENGER

  • Zane Binder June 23, 2010, 3:10 pm

    I am mortified and disgusted so many of my fellow investors don’t understand why we’re in Afghanistan. Remember 9/11? And remember the Taliban both actively and passively helped 19 hijackers kill more than 2,300 Americans? That many had to jump out windows to escape the flames? Some of my fellow investors comment today it’s a war for profit and many other reasons, but not one (so far) has mentioned 9/11 or the nation’s safety. I am a veteran of two wars and would help in this one if I wasn’t so old … there is NO excuse for you younger people not knowing that we’re fighting to safeguard our wives and kids re: 9/11. Investors, wake up! You won’t HAVE Wall Street at all if you act like scared little girls and obfuscate the reasons we’re in Afghanistan to suit your political agenda.

    • Rich June 23, 2010, 7:25 pm

      Saudi son Al Qaeda left Afghanistan a long time ago.
      Taliban fighting to preserve their country
      as Founding Fathers did in 1776…

    • SDavid June 23, 2010, 7:39 pm

      Maybe the money spent in the middle east would be better spent fortifying US’s own borders? How can the US control someone else’s back yard if they can’t take care of their own?

  • johnjay June 23, 2010, 2:55 pm

    Highwater, you are right about Obama the puppet.
    It is clear that he is in over his head, and has most likely told the power brokers he is not interested in another term. Hence his concert going, golf playing, etc., too much stress, and the BP Gulf spill was the last straw.
    He is not Douglas MacArthur by a long shot.

    A Lee, resignation or firing is indeed an out for McChrystal from a hopeless task.
    Once he retires, he can make the talk show rounds to promote his book, and say I told you so when we get kicked out of Afghanistan. He may even run for Congress.

  • GMC June 23, 2010, 2:53 pm

    We learn nothing from history.

    • dlweld June 23, 2010, 5:14 pm

      Correction: we learn one thing from history: – that we learn nothing from history

  • A Lee June 23, 2010, 1:37 pm

    Seriously, you guys think this was a slip? Either he’s batsh!t crazy to do such a thing, or he wants out – this reeks of calculation. He NEEDS the president to take his resignation so he’s forcing that to happen, in a most interesting way. The real story will come out later.

    • Steve June 23, 2010, 3:27 pm

      Great message – on point – well thought out – delivered beautifully.

    • mario cavolo June 23, 2010, 5:16 pm

      I agree….Odds on he knows exactly what he’s doing, did, said, planned, he knows the background bias of the publication he was interviewed by, etc. He’s setting it up and in fact if he wants out, that’s fine and there’s nothing wrong with him orchestrating his exit strategy. Many of us have done similar when deciding move on out of a particular corporate position for example. I have a very close friend in the middle of this kind of situation now. He knows its coming to an end, for whatever reasons, and he’s weighing and strategizing very carefully his exit options.

  • Highwater June 23, 2010, 9:28 am

    Rick,
    …(I figure if Tahoe Billy’s drivel is still up on your board you might allow mine)
    First of all, I enjoy and appreciate your insights and what you “bring to the table” of financial reporting.

    But please, leave President [Obama] out of this. It is by now SO painfully obvious that he is clearly just another puppet/b**tch of the military-industrial-oil-banking complex “power elite” war profiteers. When OH WHEN will Obama fans notice the knife in their back? Or notice the blood of innocents on his hands? Neither of which are accidental.
    Can’t we talk about hidden pivots or where the Dow and gold are likely to meet? or skiing or fly fishing…please?

    • Steve June 23, 2010, 3:25 pm

      Yep,

      Ya All go fishing, go skiing, and talk about how everyone will be taken care of.

      This country was Free because my Family took the cannon and powder to Concord Bridge in A.D. 1775. Ya ALL walked the streets in relative safety because I put my blood into the Soil while a peace officer. And The Family has bones in defense in every conflict except Afghanistan – and who knows they might get my youngest son yet – he is only 26 years old.

      Yep ! The obligation of Citizenship – to confront the tyranny of Obama and Congress means YA ALL should go fishing, and talk about the good times in a fiat money government illegitimacy.

      YA ! It makes me angry when someone spits in my face, and denies the blood my People give to try to retain what Obama is trying to destroy.

      The message to go fishing, and skiing just plain SUCKS

  • DG June 23, 2010, 6:48 am

    I thought Obama wanted transparency.

    Obama picked Biden. You are gonna catch some flak just standing next to smilin’ “big f-n’ deal” Joe. He’s your guy. I have often wondered what pics does Joe have?

    It all seems so FUBAR. The economic policy of fattening up Wall Street alone, skewering all others is FUBAR. We have 7 million homes wanting to be sold, not even listed, and we are encouraging builders to build more…MMS? Our energy policy? Obama turning his back on Israel?

    Oh, and talk about a great plan – pass the healthcare feed trough, solving none of the expense issues, and worry about the 20 million illegal Mexicans squatting here later. You might want to count how many are in the bar before yelling, “Drinks on me!” It just makes no sense. None of it. It just reeks of a guy who came into office thinking that “all you need is love”, America is boundlessly rich, add some good intentions, and it will all be so much better – with no worthwhile experience or understanding. At some point, it will be so hard, he is going to give up – I hope. And then, change.

    When he made that statement that “maximizing tax receipts is not paramount, fairness is” I knew we were doomed. That is just plain stupid. Like John Edwards suggesting we should tax unrealized capital gains (he did, and 20% of the population wanted him).
    The one thing that I found very attractive about this mess is that it indicates to me that there is a healthy dose of disgust and contempt that the military has for its government. This will be reassuring when TSHTF and our local law enforcement is the Nat Guard. Together, we can talk smack about the POTUS and exchange ammo!

  • TahoeBilly June 23, 2010, 6:10 am

    Rich,

    You don’t pull punches! How earth can we know what our military really does, “nation build”? Fill the potholes here @#!holes!

    I am so afraid of guys with towels on their heads I want to take my shoes off at the airport!

    How can we know anything when it’s all a big secret?

  • Benjamin June 23, 2010, 6:09 am

    It should surprise no one when we finally do pull out of Afghanistan without accomplishment. Our reasons for staying this long was to prevent the inevitable. But a power vacuum will ensue because we can’t stop it from doing so. And we’ll have to live with the reality that not everyone in the world has our interests at heart and we can’t make them do so.

    As for McChrystal’s Big Bad Plan, they shouldn’t call it COIN. Call it the same they call our Constitution: TOILETPAPER!

    Let’s see… A surge of troops which will, among other things, live among the population in order to foster trust and cooperation. That’s called quartering troops in times of… Well, we’re not exactly in times of peace than we are at war, at least if COIN is approved for Afghanistan. Think about the twisted logic of the whole thing. We’re at war, but we desire peace. To that end, we’re not at war, we’re just at some political/social disadvantage which importing of more troops for the locals to make friends with will somehow change.

    The founders realized what this kind of thing is for. We’re either at war or we’re not! Making friends is not a legit use of the military. And it doesn’t foster peace, though it may at times force cooperation. It only encourages more insurgency and less trust. But somehow it will work in Afghanistan because some army big-wig who made disparaging remarks about Obama (who the hell hasn’t, though?!) said it will!?

    COIN is just heads up the tails, is what it is. Wall Street is blind, our military leaders are blind… We never were going to win. This is just the Pentagon’s way of passing time until we’re forced to leave. No skin off their noses any more than it is off the President’s and Congress’s.

  • andy June 23, 2010, 5:43 am

    I think there is no question was insubordinate to his Commander in Chief and deserves some form of discipline.

    Under Bush the Lesser, U.S. Army Major-General Antonio Taguba and General Eric Shinseki were both forced to resign as a consequence of their Congressional testimonies—where their opinions were officially sought.

    Here’s a little about their circumstances:
    The Army launched an investigation into torture at Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq in spring 2004. U.S. Army Major-General Antonio Taguba, who led the investigation, later testified to Congress that the mistreatment resulted from poor leadership, a “lack of discipline, no training whatsoever, and no supervision” of the troops.
    General Taguba was later asked to resign.

    Eric Shinseki: After General Shinseki, the Army’s chief of staff, told Congress that the occupation of Iraq could require “several hundred thousand troops,” he was derided by Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz. Then, wrote the Houston Chronicle, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld “took the unusual step of announcing that Gen. Eric Shinseki would be leaving when his term as Army chief of staff end[ed].” Retired, June 2003.

    I believe there were a number of other generals and high raking military personnel who were forced to resign simply because they gave their “on the ground” opinions and assessments of Iraq that was in opposition to Bush’s “vision”.

    Neither Taguba nor Shinseki slighted their Commander in Chief. In their official testimonies were both trying to better military actions and procedures.

    It the standard of conduct to get tossed from the military is to merely has an opposing opinion from the president, then McChrystal should go.

    I’m not saying that I believe that dissent or differences I opinion should not be tolerated, on the contrary. But to call the president a “weakling”? that’s out of line. He’s not irreplaceable.

    • Steve June 23, 2010, 3:12 pm

      IT IS ONLY INSUBORDINATION IF IT IS UNTRUE, A LIE, AN INTENTIONAL MISREPRESENTATION

      Fact is, Obama is engaged in tyrannical abuse of power according to President James Madison.

      It is the DUTY of every American to stand up and oppose the tyrannical abuses of domestic terror.

      TAKE ON THE MESSAGE, NOT THE MESSENGER

      DENY WHAT THE GENERAL SAID AS AN INTENTIONAL LIE – I will listen to your word and weigh them against what I know about the tyranny of Obama and congress.

      Then get over the successful propaganda of the u.s. democracy in rebellion supported by 50% of the population, and the illegals; all with hands out, instead of what can I do to stop the illegitimate practice of democracy in OUR FREE Republic.

      As for me; Give me the TRUTH as a historical fact – and forget the consensus of opinion that Obama lying along with congress as a profession is the way to GO

    • Rich June 23, 2010, 7:19 pm

      No doubt many in the Muslim world believe it is their time for destiny with the 12th Imam Mahdi rising from occultation with Jesus and the Prophets.
      McChrystal’s brilliant counter-insurgency success in Iraq indisputable. Although part of the interview took place getting hammered in a Parisian nightclub, they knew what they were doing, asking the public for help with another debilitating war lost war in Afghanistan, the graveyard of empires. McChrystal is in position to know the puppetmeisters may have no intention of winning the war, and may only be interested in profiteering and culling the herd.
      Thanks to Zbigniew Brzezinski’s Grand Chessboard middle-eastern strategy that made Navy Sub vet Jimmy Carter a sterile lame duck, US has a ring of sitting duck military installations and aircraft carriers around Iran and Middle Eastern petrol-reservoirs.
      China, Iran and Russia none too happy, doing their best to deploy deadly cruise missiles thanks to Brown Clinton BA LK Loral missile technology transfer to destabilize US/Israel power with N Korean, Syrian, Turkish and Venezuelan help, even though BP-CNPC won the Iraq oil auction US deserved for toppling Saddam, but lost because they overstayed their welcome.
      The author of antiwar 60’s Rolling Stone article, a former embedded Iraq journalist, spent almost a month traveling with McChrystal and his wife due to the Iceland ash keeping him from returning to USA from Paris where the interview began, so the message was not a mistake.
      With rumour Bill Ayers appointed to 0Care Board and Immanuel dual Israeli citizen leaving, it may be McChrystal trying to alert America to DC being commandered by 60s radicals who still want to tear America apart and down, blow US up, one a Muslim bowing to terrorist paymasters to boot.
      If the monopoly media had any integrity, they would
      cover the Birther Chicago Criminal Radical story instead of dissing it out of hand.
      We have a chance this Fall to get rid of all incumbents who created this crisis debt hole spiral robbing America blind.
      Meanwhile, appears BP doing best to drive petroleum prices to the moon…

  • johnjay June 23, 2010, 5:25 am

    The quicker we get our ass kicked in Afghanistan, the sooner we can get out of there and stop the waste of billions of dollars and the lives, limbs, and sanity of our forlorn troops. The schmucks in the Senate plan to balance the budget by cutting $25 from UI checks, while throwing away trillions in foreign wars. McChrystal is very likely seeking a way out so he does not become William Westmoreland who “won every battle until he lost the war” in Vietnam, telling everyone “the end is in sight” from 1964 to 1968.
    The Federal government is ceding National Park land in Arizona to the coyotes and drug cartels while our troops are everywhere on the planet but the USA. I think Germany, Japan, and Korea can afford to maintain a military of their very own for starters.

    • mario cavolo June 23, 2010, 12:33 pm

      …not to mention the lives, limbs and sanity of civilian’s lives also being killed or devastated…

  • mario cavolo June 23, 2010, 5:17 am

    BTW, not one person in a million thinks the top is in, giving several people here one in a million status….

    …which means it is. DaBoyz could pull off the past year’s short squeeze steamroller from those lower levels, but continue it again from these levels?….much harder to justify the numbers at this juncture and especially considering the seeming slowdown/tightening/market weakness we’re seeing in China and Europe, not to mention all the other nightmares…am I bloviating? Nope, just observing. 🙂

    The General created a big “lose face” moment for Obama. Here in China, to cause another person to lose face publicly is a cultural top of the list no-no. It is the worst thing you can do to another person, to shame them, to make them look bad in public. So much so, that in fact you can often make yourself a victim of the classic Chinese revenge response which is to quietly in the background get back at you.

    Cheers, Mario

  • Rich June 23, 2010, 3:54 am

    Gotta watch those Afghan drugs, hashish, Islamic Terrorism and opium…
    Seriously, it would not be inaccurate to note DC generals once again are not winning an American War for profit, perhaps the fifth since Korea.
    General McChrystal might be more than a little stressed right about now with the K offensive, undermanned, covertly opposing China, Iran and Russia, knowing the Taliban heard our Afghanistan withdrawal next summer.
    Maybe it is time to let deflation defaults end the US Warfare welfare government media complex tearing our Constitution, lives and prosperity apart.
    BTW, not one person in a million thinks the top is in, giving several people here one in a million status.
    Here follows an amazing list of expensive US military interventions. Then there are 20 million estimated illegal aliens on government welfare according to the CS Monitor, or part of the drug cartel…
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_United_States_military_operations

  • Martin Snell June 23, 2010, 3:38 am

    Not sure if we read the same article.

    McCrystal is having a hard time convincing his own troops on the validity of implementing COIN, and the “assault” on Kandahar is now a “rising tide of security” along with $90 million in aid.

    From the article: http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/17390/119236?RS_show_page=0
    “But however strategic they may be, McChrystal’s new marching orders have caused an intense backlash among his own troops. Being told to hold their fire, soldiers complain, puts them in greater danger. “Bottom line?” says a former Special Forces operator who has spent years in Iraq and Afghanistan. “I would love to kick McChrystal in the nuts. His rules of engagement put soldiers’ lives in even greater danger. Every real soldier will tell you the same thing.””

    &&&&&&&&

    The rules of engagement were implemented to bring civilian Afghani casualties down to zero or something close to it. Moral considerations were a factor, but there was also the danger that each new civilian death was bringing the Afghanis closer to viewing U.S. troops as the enemy. This is still the case, even though civilian deaths are down sharply.

    Under the circumstances, probably the best we can do is hold the Taliban to a draw. But that is not an outcome, and the mere intention of withdrawing troops on a schedule can only lead to defeat. We shouldn’t be surprised, then, to see that this fatal contradiction has created serious dissension in the ranks. RA

    • Rich June 23, 2010, 10:00 pm

      From the RS link:
      “The very people that COIN seeks to win over – the Afghan people – do not want us there.”
      Hearts and Minds the same reason we lost Korea, Vietnam and Iraq. End of story, end of engagement.
      Better to defend US borders and stop spending, regulating and taxing our way into obscurity…

    • Rich June 23, 2010, 10:01 pm

      Also from the RS link:
      McChrystal covered up Prof Football Draft Pat Tillman’s death by friendly fire…

  • Bob June 23, 2010, 3:08 am

    Rick, I agree with your sentiment and come from the right wing myself, but there is something deeper here that I don’t believe anyone has mentioned. The General expressed himself (and I think he’s right) knowingly before an anti military, left wing rag in what has to be a subconscious act of self destruction. I have to ask to what degree that bent toward self destruction might carry over to his military policies? If the pressures he is dealing with between the responsibilities of a war on the one hand, and a President who is himself anti military on the other, have brought Mc Chrystal to such a point, then for the good of the nation he should step down. I hate to see it, because I think he’s a good man. But he’s a warrior, not a politician and the squeeze he is in may be affecting him. I’m just saddened to see the press handling this like he’s some inept rube. It’s the Commander in Chief who’s battling hard for the inept title here.