Tiny Cyprus Re-Opens Europe’s Can of Worms

“What rough beast, its hour come round at last, Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?

With the Dow Industrials trading at record heights last week, Wall Street and its news-media shills boldly ratcheted up the hubris to levels unseen since the dot-com bubble popped exactly 13 years ago.  All news is good news these days, it would seem — especially fraudulent employment data spun to suggest that boom times are about to return to the U.S.  As far as we’re concerned, however, the real news is in Cyprus, where the latest eurobank bailout perfectly describes the sort of seemingly minor trouble that could cause the global financial system to implode overnight.  Will Cyprus’ banking problems prove to be the black swan that author Nassim Taleb famously described?  Unfortunately, for reasons Taleb took pains to explain, we won’t know the answer until it’s too late.  But it’s hardly inconceivable that this measly €13 billion bailout could trigger a sequence of events with global implications.

On the surface, it’s hard to see what could be even remotely troubling about the sight of nervous depositors queueing outside the Bank of Cyprus. As far as investors in the U.S. are concerned, the depositors might as well be Yap Islanders trying to exchange paper receipts for stone money. Trouble is, Cyprus is a major haven for the untold loot of Russian tycoons. And while it’s one thing for Cypriot riff-raff to get skittish about the safety of their nest eggs, the Russian oligarchs are another matter. Were a whiff of fear to hit their sensitive nostrils, deposits they’ve stashed all over Europe would scurry for safety elsewhere, presumably into U.S. Treasury paper and – wouldn’t this be a novel turn of events? – gold.

Jeopardy for Depositors

They have good reason to be skittish, since this latest bailout will expose depositors and certain bondholders to moral hazard risks as never before.  For depositors, the “impairment” will come in the form of a 6.75% levy on deposits of less than €100,000 and 9.9% for sums above that amount.  Bondholders’ comeuppance will come via a “bail-in” increasing the witholding tax on capital income and restructuring and recapitalizing the banks. It was unclear whether the provisions would apply only to junior bondholders, or to sovereign backers as well.

A knowledgeable assessment of the gathering storm can be found at ZeroHedge, a web site with more readers — and, perforce, more credibility — than The Financial Times, The Wall Street Journal and The New York Times put together.  If bullion and dollar-based assets are not up sharply on Monday in the wake of this developing story, the financial world is far more complacent than we might have imagined.  In any case, it seems very late in the game to be jumping on U.S. stocks just because the mainstream media’s fulsome green-shoots story has turned into a full-blown Garden of Eden hallucination.

  • Chris T. March 19, 2013, 7:03 pm

    bc wrote:
    “All deposits will flee to the north strengthening Deutschbank while gutting the banks of the PIIGS plus France.”

    What do you mean “gutting”
    They’ve been gutted, their own doing, for years.
    If the US big-bank-boys are walking-zombies, the PIGS+Fr banks are barely stumbling zombies.

    As to yourt”taking it to the Anglo bankers” comment above;
    WISH IT WERE SO!
    It’s about time “our” hubris comes to an end. Whether internal or external, who cares.

    But think your assessment is wrong:
    It’s the enrich-the-big-boys system, and that is so much more fun when co-equally joined, than fought.
    After all, have you seen DB, UBS, etc moving towards the Anglo system?
    Of course, because it works for them.

    And overall, your German-domination theory just totally misdiagnoses the thought of the German body-politic:
    they are such convinced Euro(process)-philes it, plus CO2/global warming is their modern religion, brooking no dissent.

    Don’t believe me? Just see how things that would be seen as “healthy” patriotism here are judged in main-stream Germany:
    if the person being judged can avoid the accusation of right-wing fashistic tendencies, he can count himself very lucky.

    Their center of thought (that mythical middle ground) is solidly on the left using a US metric.

  • Jill March 18, 2013, 9:33 pm

    Yep, Goldman analysts– the best contrarian indicators in the world. Doesn’t work 100% of the time, but darn near to it. Just one more example here. Remember June 2012. Here’s a call from Goldman– letting folks know who use them as a contrarian indicator, that it was time to back up the truck:

    http://www.businessinsider.com/goldman-go-short-2012-6

  • Dave March 18, 2013, 7:10 pm

    Goldman said today re Cyprus: “This is a biggie”

    • bc March 18, 2013, 9:34 pm

      It is a frontal assault on the Anglo dominated (read, Fed/BOE) world banking system. It is Europe (Germany mostly) telling the City boyz and their friends on Wall Street to piss off, no more money wash/tax havens inside the EU. More to come for sure. A biggie indeed.

  • A. de Orleans-B. March 18, 2013, 10:09 am

    I would not read too much in the Cyprus event.

    A fringe banking system had accepted an inordinate amount of “hot” money and, predictably, found out that it is not so easy to lend it profitably to solvent borrowers — a necessary step if a bank wants to remain in business.

    The rest of Europe watched and waited — when enough of their borrowers became delinquent and cries for help arrived, a “solution with a fine” has been offered and accepted.

    The lesson for other fringe banking systems is clear.

    The outcome may be slightly deflationary, but less so compared to a full banking crisis.

    Yes, for a while any future market swing may be traced back to the “Cyprus event”, a great rug under which a lot of other real stupidities will be hidden under.

    &&&&&&&

    My E-Mini S&P analysis for today correctly saw The Boys as accumulating index futures overnight — as though they viewed Cyprus’ problems as a shakedown opportunity. Even so, whatever we might “read” into this seemingly small crisis, the financial system is as fragile and prone to collapse as was Europe’s political order in the summer of 1914. Anything could bring the whole house of cards tumbling down — and
    something will. RA

  • gary leibowitz March 18, 2013, 7:05 am

    There goes the excuse to correct from an obviously over-extended market. SPX should first hold at 1525 area, if not the lowest point should be 1495. The possibly last correction before the final push up. I also see the dollar going to move up as well, after this news dies down.

    My original assumption was a top in May/June period. Still seems logical. As for Zerohedge having credibility, I guess if you keep believing the end already happened years ago despite the levitation act by the stock markets, in a strange way you will be right. If the last 4 years is an illusion and the masses were fooled, perhaps the next crash will just be another illusion where the masses will see thru it, while this group falls for it. Illusions don’t stop simply because you happen to believe in one version as opposed to another.

    In any event it seems most likley that the SP500 hit new highs before it is all over. The chart pattern also suggests we have more time to fill in, and more vertical movement. The easy way to tell if this is true is follow this next drop. I expect a strong support at 1495 or higher. If it breaks below for 2 whole trading days you might get a very early Christams present. I personally give those odds a 1 in 100 shot. If the long-shot does occur I will be placing those shorts by the handful.

    • Rick Ackerman March 18, 2013, 4:44 pm

      I’ve made today’s E-Mini S&P tout visible to all so that you can see for yourself whether I was “fooled” by the Cyprus shakedown. As for ZeroHedge, they are the most-read source of financial news in the world because, unlike you, they consistently see through the crap.

    • gary leibowitz March 18, 2013, 7:09 pm

      Rick, I am not attacking your technical skills and system. I only try to point out the extreme bias and inability to see the world for what it is. Zerohedge and this blog seem to extract the worse aspects of everything and conclude it should already have failed, and since it didn’t its because of the evil dominating all powerful government intervention. Since it’s impossible to disprove a phantom theory, 4 years can go by with a doubling of the markets and earnings, and still declare your theory intact. If you were to use this logic in explaining away why your technical system isn’t working at all you would not have any subscribers. Clearly it’s the results that matter. To continue on the same path without making adjustments along the way, such as anticipating the 4 year rebound, is not a good way to invest. To view the world as either all good or evil, and place whole segments of the economy in either camp is stuff of screenwriters.

      Me, I still expect a correction to continue till first week in April, followed by the last wave up before a slow but painful fall ending late 2014. There is a 40 year cycle that seems to have a very good track record for predicting bottoms. The assumption is also that after 2014 we will have fits and starts but still go higher from the 2014 bottom until 2020. That doesn’t sound like a fast bottom feeding market, but rather something like the 70’s. Just one mans interpretation of where we are and will be.

      &&&&&

      I never said you were “attacking” my system, only that you were ignorant of it and the bullish gains it has produced. Your ignorance wouldn’t matter but for the fact that everything you post suggests that I and nearly everyone else in this forum is clueless about how the real world works. It is you who is clueless — for suggesting that the rally in stocks is other than a fraud. You keep talking about corporate earnings, but what does it tell you when real wages have been stagnant since the 1970s? You see every fraudulent statistical uptick as vindicating your rosy point of view. Meanwhile, I have yet to see you treat a statistic in a way that differs from the way the lying, ignorant f**ks at CNBC intend that we should treat it.

      You seem to understand that this epic hoax can only end badly, so why take everyone to task when they fundamentally agree with you? Also, you act as though it were impossible for the collapse to occur…tomorrow. In fact, it could happen at any moment, almost certainly caused by something none of us will have imagined.

      RA

    • gary leibowitz March 18, 2013, 7:30 pm

      BTW, all the major news agency has reported the same concerns and unprecedented move to penalize the depositors. This is clearly a foolish move by a EU controlling nations that want to stop supporting the world. I guess they believe most of the pain will fall on foreigners and mafia deposits.

      http://finance.yahoo.com/blogs/daily-ticker/why-cyprus-bail-bigger-deal-think-141844402.html

      http://finance.yahoo.com/news/cyprus-rescue-risks-backlash-000300230.html

      These 2 articles are among dozens that show their concern, placed by the mainstream media. No need to get the “truth” from Zerohedge. They only focus on the worse case scenarios. Do they ever put a positive slant on anything? If we lived our life as they present it, what a dead depressing life we must lead.

      &&&&&

      Do you really believe that all of the guys who post at ZeroHedge lead dead, depressing lives?
      RA

    • gary leibowitz March 18, 2013, 8:10 pm

      If they see the world as so bleak how can they enjoy themselves? Do the ones preaching that the end of the world is upon us have a good laugh now and then?

      If someone is that pessimistic about the current affairs and even more doom and gloom about our future what would give them relief? How does one live a happy life when they view the wolrd as being so unhappy.

      Just my assumptions, not based on any sociological study. Perhaps I am wrong. I hope so.

    • redwilldanaher March 18, 2013, 8:53 pm

      I know that Gary knows its all a lie, he just chooses to ignore it all because nothing matters apparently until it does…

      “When it becomes serious, you have to lie.”

      -Jean Claude Juncker, PM of Luxembourg, and the head of the Eurogroup council of eurozone finance ministers

      May, 2011

      http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-03-18/end-systemic-trust-canary-just-died

    • gary leibowitz March 18, 2013, 10:16 pm

      Red, if a 5,000 pound boulder was to prevent you from taking a specific path would you lament and get angry over it? I have never disputed the fact that this government is ringing up a pile of debt to try and “normalize” the world economies. I also knew for decades that corporate america has become the dominant decision maker. My argument all along was to profit from the market by understanding how the market behaves. The market is a macrocosom of individual behavior. We always down play serious problems until we can no longer ignore them.

      I really don’t understand the dispute? I am calling for this all to get very messy within the next few months. Sorry I am so calm about it. I can’t make a dent in that 5,000 pound boulder, so why try. I equate the boulder and this situation as an act of nature.

  • bc March 18, 2013, 5:39 am

    I smell a great big German rat in this. No one does this by accident or stupidity. This is Germany saying ,”What say we stop playing this game and just admit we Germans are now the defacto great power of Europe.” I expect they are ready (having planned for this) for a bank run in the south. All deposits will flee to the north strengthening Deutschbank while gutting the banks of the PIIGS plus France. Capital controls will block funds going to non EU destinations plus UK. Russia will be thrown a bone of some sort; perhaps dropping Europe support for Israel and normalizing relations with Iran? My crystal grows dark here. Always moving the future is… Makes it hard to see.

    • Carol March 18, 2013, 3:22 pm

      Agreed bc, there is no way da boyz didn’t see a potential for a bank run and a “black swan” event. This has absolutely been carefully prepared and planned out. But for what reason and what “solution” is going to be put forward in the Hegelian Dialectic they are setting up here. One has to wonder.

  • fallingman March 18, 2013, 4:23 am

    Important post Rick. Thanks.

    Hard to believe these morons are screwing with bank depositors. Do they WANT to spark a bank run?

    I could be wrong, but this has the feel of a real crisis-maker. IMO, it won’t take much to shift us from a stable disequilibrium to an unstable disequilibrium.

    Think avalanche.

    Timing is always a wildcard, and I’ve been impressed at how long the Powerz have been able to keep the plates spinning, but it really is just a matter of time. I don’t think the broad outlines of the meltdown are very much in question.

  • John Jay March 18, 2013, 4:20 am

    What has happened to people’s bank deposits in Cyprus is just the next step in the theft of savings.
    Greenspan and Bernanke have been more or less stripping US CD holders of their savings with ZIRP for years.
    The most generous 1 year CD now pays about 1.25% before State and Federal taxes.
    And with real inflation probably running north of 5% for years thanks to QE, confiscation of the proles savings account has been going on for some time now.
    A 10% “Tax” on your balance would simply be the next step.
    It is simply a question of degree.
    I see ZB and ZN did a gap up tonight at the open.
    Money looking for a safe haven here I imagine.
    It all seems to be closing in on the world financial system.
    NG up, CL down.
    All the currencies down vs. the $ except the Yen.
    What a madhouse.

  • Craig March 18, 2013, 2:31 am

    “Mr. Gold”, Jim Sinclair made an astute take on this situation:
    “The wire reports on the Cyprus situation are working overtime to try to make the case that 80% of the deposits belong to the people of Cyprus, and only 20% of the deposits belong to the Russians. That’s absolutely false. After 1985, when the ‘Robber Barrons’ of Russia took over the general economics of Russia, that was the transformation from the KGB to private business. The primary place for exported Russian funds was Cyprus.
    Now, there is one leader in the world that would be very dangerous to challenge and that is Putin of Russia….
    Continued at:
    http://kingworldnews.com/kingworldnews/KWN_DailyWeb/Entries/2013/3/16_Sinclair_-_One_Of_The_Most_Important_Events_In_History_%26_Gold.html

    “Eventually it reaches a point of essential alienation, where it can no longer pretend to represent the governed. The American government is now the most powerful human organization that has ever existed. It has made a stupid habit of exercising power arbitrarily, uninhibited by moral or constitutional principle. It is not a conspiracy masterminded by some cunning genius at the center; it is a system of power which large numbers of greedy and ambitious people have learned to use. It has ceased to be a problem for Americans only; it has become a problem for a large part of the human race.” — Joseph Sobran

  • BigTom March 18, 2013, 12:23 am

    Yep – I believe Cyprus is to ‘da boyz’ in Russia as are the Cayman Islands are to ‘da boyz’ here in Pleasantville, USA.
    Is that an omen for what goes around comes around? It’s 4:20 pm here sunday evening mountain time and gold is at $1606 and silver at $29.07. See if ‘da boyz’ step on dat!