Plunge in Gold, Silver Just a Healthy Correction

Bullion bears had better not get their hopes too high in the wake of yesterday’s nasty plunge in precious metals. The price of an ounce of gold on Comex fell $40 from high to low, or about 3%, and silver fared even worse, falling from 23.53 to 22.47, or nearly 4.5%.  We see this action as purely corrective, however, since none of the factors that have been driving silver and gold higher have changed. For starters, the Fed remains committed to massive new rounds of quantitative easing, which can only feed on itself by driving buyers away from future Treasury auctions. The global financial system is further roiled by Japan’s abortive efforts to hold down the yen, and by China’s simultaneous efforts to push it up.  Bottom line, the world’s major currencies, all of them fundamentally worthless, remain in a hopeless state of chaos relative to each other. If that is bearish for gold and silver, then this week’s toxic spill in the Danube is bullish for Hungarian tourism.

If the dollar were about to turn powerfully higher, it would have gotten past both peaks yesterday without needing a rest

We’d anticipated short-term trouble for bullion in yesterday’s commentary, which bore the following headline: A Hair-Trigger Alert for Bullion-Watchers.  The trigger we were referring to was a rally in the U.S. dollar, which has been in a relentless decline since early June. Were the dollar to reverse direction with a dead-cat bounce or perhaps something more, that would put downward pressure on gold and silver prices. This dynamic was present yesterday to some degree, although the NYBOT Dollar Index (DXY) began the day on weakness, breaking beneath some Hidden Pivot supports we’d flagged for subscribers. This occurred overnight, but when U.S. markets opened Thursday morning, the dollar reversed sharply, and that’s when gold and silver began to fall in earnest.

Some Clues

Although it’s impossible to predict exactly how far the dollar will rise, Hidden Pivot analysis over the next two or three days should yield some useful clues. For now, we can tell you that DXY’s move off the launching pad was not particularly impressive.  Powerful rallies typically begin with unpaused thrusts that exceed at least two prior peaks on the hourly chart. If you look at the chart above, however, you’ll see that DXY pushed past only a single peak yesterday, and that it has needed to pull back for a running start before taking on a second (#2). While it is speculative at this point to pronounce the rally dead on arrival, it will quickly sink into the dead-cat-bounce category if subsequent thrusts over the next few days fail to live up to our two-peaks rule.

(If you’d like to have Rick’s Picks commentary delivered free each day to your e-mail box, click here.)

  • Ken October 10, 2010, 11:26 am

    Historically – I understand The Gold Silver ration is 16 – 1. I believe it is something like 64 – 1 with current gold price. Are silver prices going to rise and close that gap and if so what do people think Silver could reach? Ken

  • mario cavolo October 10, 2010, 5:51 am

    In a state of financial crisis, these idiot maniacs in charge take care of themselves not their country.

    Bailing out rich people in charge of banks without even getting an accounting of how the money will be allocated, for example…mind boggling

    Printing hundreds of billions which the banks are holding onto instead of lending out….mindboggling…

    Declaring a payment to every “not rich” citizen in the country…equally but not more mindboggling, and that would put the money, which is being printed out of nowhere into many hands where it would do the country the most good to get back on track. An automatic, final decision based on income tiers from last years’ tax returns. If you’re below $40,000/year or below and you’re over 18, you get a $15,000 cash deposit in your bank account courtesy of Uncle Sam. If your income is 40 to 70k, you get $10,000. Above that, no dice. Add it up and the total would be far less than the robbery they have perpetrated on the country to date.

    They make these other insane decisions and somehow push them through, past, around the required approvals by Congress and the Senate. Why don’t these maniacs do the right thing, the right thing for the COUNTRY AND ITS CITIZENS?

    Cheers, Mario

    • F. Beard October 10, 2010, 1:22 pm

      Glad to see you’re on board, Mario. Thanks. But let’s err on the side of generosity. The minimum distribution should be enough to pay down every underwater mortgage to its current market price level. Plus the Bible mandates a minimum repayment for theft of DOUBLE (maximum = seven-fold?) and make no mistake, fractional reserve lending in a government enforced monopoly money supply is theft. Who should be allowed to extend credit in OTHER people’s goods and services?!

  • F. Beard October 9, 2010, 10:25 pm

    That is what is happening, and it’s pretty obvious by now that the central bank’s efforts to counter deflation have been completely overwhelmed. RA

    Time for a bailout of the debtors? And the savers too? All it would take is a nice big fat check from the US Treasury to every US adult combined with leverage restrictions on the banks to preclude serious inflation. Both borrowers and savers can be bailed out and even the banks in nominal terms.
    Debt forgiveness is Biblical (Deuteronomy 15, Leviticus 25).

    And no new government debt is needed. All that is needed is for the US Treasury to assert its sovereignty and issue the debt-free money.

    “Money printing”? Well, the banks “printed” temporary money (credit) with 20-30 to 1 leverage to blow the bubble. A bailout combined with leverage restrictions would merely replace some of that temporary money with debt-free permanent money.

    But let’s not hurry. Watching a fundamentally dishonest money and banking system implode is fascinating. I feel sorry for the innocent victims though, so maybe we should hurry.

  • JPM October 9, 2010, 7:41 pm

    Dear Mike, during the last week two events gave a shot
    to PM’s. First the BoJ announcement; I just ask you
    whether you think that there is much difference between
    rates at .25% ands rates “between 0 and .25% depending on circumstances”, in the BoJ own wording. Of course some market makers interprete it as more QE down the line and jump to conclusions. Then on Friday came the
    job report, which was essentially as expected because
    the Census workers layoffs. On the other hand there was
    some huge selloff on Thursday which caused the breakdown. These three facts together plus the sudden up and downs associated to them make me wonder which of them are manipulation and which reflect
    real market behaviour. This is why I won’t join the
    “this time is different” brigade and expect some serious
    correction down the line.

    As to you Cosmo, it is more than fifty years since I started using as a signature JPM and won’t change it just because there is some other JPM around. As regards the gold bull, I started buying my first gold in the late seventies and it was a poor investment because
    I arrived too late to it. Then, around 1995 I realized that
    CBs were cheating on honest savers and started buying
    until recently this year; my last ounces were paid 1180,
    even though until 2003 my investment suffered big losses, especially between 1999 and 2001, the time of the infamous BoE auctions. But as I said to a friend in
    2000 the bull would begin after the end of those auctions. As a matter of fact, this is exactly what happened, just check the dates.

    So, Cosmo, the only thing I can tell you is that you chose the wrong guy by a mile. And if you happen to be
    just excited and cannot control your emotions, try to
    relax or you might make bigger (financial) mistakes.

    Yours truly,

    JPM

  • JPM October 8, 2010, 11:27 pm

    What happened on Thursday with PM’s should be taken as a warning to those who think that a bull market is a one way road. Try to immagine what would have happened if USDI had climbed to 78 on Friday. But FOREX was surprisingly terse then, which suggests to me that something bigger may be in store. If this is the case, Fridays’s behaviour in PM’s might have been a second (local) top and an opportunity to leave the market for those who cannot afford a serious correction.

    JPM

    • mikeck October 8, 2010, 11:52 pm

      JP,

      I was hoping for a more serious correction…it is starting to look like Eric King, et all, may be correct…this time is different…getting rid of those FRNs at the first opportunity might be the best option this time around.

      Mike

    • cosmo October 9, 2010, 6:48 pm

      Hi JPM
      True to your name, throwing cold water on the bull market is expected. This kind of action has been happening repeatedly for the 8 years I have been invested in gold by your namesake, takedowns of much larger than Thursdays are normal by now. I get a good laugh each time because I can see the manipulation for what it is, desperation by the CB to conceal their fraud. Gold would have to go a LONG way down before I even started to think that the bull had died…

      “…a serious correction”…what, all the way back to $1000… hahaha

  • andequip October 8, 2010, 6:48 pm

    I found this on the internet. This seems to be a radical departure to the usual “everything’s OK” viewpoint.

    Ben Bernanke’s comments of Wednesday 10-6-10:

    “Let me return to the issue of longer-term fiscal sustainability. As I have discussed, projections by the CBO and others show future budget deficits and debts rising indefinitely, and at increasing rates. To be sure, projections are, to some degree, only hypothetical exercises. Almost by definition, unsustainable trajectories of deficits and debts, will never actually transpire, because creditors would never be willing to lend to a country in which the fiscal debt, relative to the national income, is rising without limit. Herbert Stein, a wise economist, once said, ‘If something cannot go on forever, it will stop.’ One way or the other, fiscal adjustments sufficient to stabilize the federal budget will certainly occur, at some point. The only real question is whether these adjustments will take place through a careful and deliberative process that weighs priorities and gives people plenty of time to adjust to changes in government programs, or tax policies, or whether the needed fiscal adjustments will be a rapid and painful response to a looming, or actual fiscal crises.”

    • keith October 9, 2010, 2:07 am

      Excellent quote
      What it insinuates is that government will exercise constraint. Hmmmmm. NOT!

  • Robert October 8, 2010, 5:49 pm

    I planned to skim some profits and thin some of my mining stock positions on Wednesday afternoon, but never got the orders in before the close, so I was naturally apprehensious watching yesterday’s action. The DXY action kept me from reaching for the Maalox all day.

    The thing I’m watching in this rally isn’t spot or futures prices, it’s premiums. Retail coin and bar premiums are cranking up at a rate not seen since late 08/early 09, and all the big name metals analysts are declaring that the Bullion Banks are paying exorbitant premium incentives to settle vault receipts for cash rather than good delivery bars. Typically, when a receipt holder accepts a cash settlement- the incentive will be enough for them to go into the spot market, buy their bullion (paying the retail markup) and still have a couple % left to play with…

    Important to note for all you less seasoned bullion speculators that rising premiums on physical bullion mean the SAME THING as rising spot prices out of the exchanges- premiums are just another way the big sellers paint the spot price charts to keep the trends from looking as “real” as they are.

    Even though the Fed declared the they were prepared to buy Treasuries direct as part of QE2, I was pontificating recently on whether QE2 will actually be a Fed program to backstop the Bullion Banks by printing the incentive dollars needed to cover the big commercial shorts as more and more longs stand for delivery on the exchanges…?

    • Bay of Pigs October 8, 2010, 6:54 pm

      Robert, Excellent comment. You have to wonder what the big shorts like JPM will have to do get out of this without taking a mortal hit? They are most likely in the crosshairs of some big players who aren’t exactly happy about doing business with them. Not a big stretch to assume this massive fraud falls to pieces if they stand for delivery.

  • Tom Paine October 8, 2010, 3:07 pm

    I knew the “beat up the gold bears” article had to be a contrary indicator, but I agree that this will probably be a healthy correction in an ongoing bull move for pms. I say this because, as Rick mentioned, the underlying fundamentals haven’t changed and PMs are not particularly overbought on weekly charts, which is something I would expect before a powerful move like this is over. Also, I would expect some divergences between momentum and price on succesive peaks, which hasn’t happened yet.

  • SDavid October 8, 2010, 1:43 pm

    As always, Rick, your HP’s keep everything in perspective. Thanks.

  • JackC October 8, 2010, 1:41 pm

    OT- with Rick’s indulgence

    Anyone have an opinion on Jim Sinclair’s TRE and Silver Wheaton (SLW)? I have always gone the physical/coin/bullion route. Never bought a precious metal stock. I suppose I could play it safe via GDX or GDXJ. Am I stupid to trust the gold guru Jim Sinclair with his TRE?

    The track records of GDX and GDXJ are very pokey compared to SLW and TRE

    Thanks!

  • Lee October 8, 2010, 11:55 am

    Gold, Silver & Rock ‘n’ Roll!

  • Benjamin October 8, 2010, 9:46 am

    Feels like late 2007 all over again (for gold and silver, anyway)!

    And unless I’m mistaken, this whole week of RP commentary has been about the metals. But still what seems barely a faint whisper in the MSM. Really makes me curious what the commentary will be like a few years from now…

  • mario cavolo October 8, 2010, 5:41 am

    I will remain steadfast in my conviction that to a very large degree these up/down trading plays will reverse once again to the greedy satisfaction and short term agendas of those running “Wall Street”. Dollar up/down, Euro up/down…speculative shenanigans in the ranges as all currencies will buy less and less over time…that’s the ultimate release valve.

    This statement is an impossibility; “…which can only feed on itself by driving buyers away from future Treasury auctions.” Impossible! A Disaster! Rising yields are the economic nuclear bomb, the very last thing the world gov’ts will ever allow in today’s economic structure. The Fed is on a course to inflation which means a course to higher interest rates? Indeed it looks that way today, but what new announcements will be made next quarter based on the market correlations then? It can not be true as even any reasonable trend upward in interest rates will be the death of global economics as we know it, yes the exact armageddon of which this site speaks. Do we all understand that in fact such an event would be global anarchy, global blood in the streets if it really happened? No, they will continue to fool the common man with their shenanigans by slowly choking their lives, a currency note buying less and less and less, a quart of milk costing more and more, which is what has been happening for the past 50 years and longer. Look at commodity prices for the past year.

    QE2 will continue unabated after election day? Who knows…nobody knows. They will make announcements they KNOW will allow the markets to go down, let the market get down to the 9500 range again, then the next unexpected spin magic announcements will be made to prop it up. I remind everyone it has already been established that they ARE running Wall Street, it IS now a much more privately controlled and manipulated tool of the economy. So what I am suggesting is not out of line, while it is disturbing and unstable.

    1. Interest rates will remain low for years to come because they must. We are Japan, get used to it. My article reviewing the point here: http://www.businessinsider.com/say-goodbye-to-yields-2010-8

    The dollar will probably float back down to its longer term support at 72-73 at the lowest and then right back up it will go…blah blah blah…the Euro’s turn to have a crisis and be traded back down…give me a break! With oil, its not so sure, because as a core needed commodity, unlike gold, maybe its price range will somehow stay down, let’s hope. If oil starts being viewed as an asset, a store of value with a corresponding price run up, that will have far more negative consequences on the economy than if it were coffee or gold.

    The dollar will not collapse and neither will treasuries because they can’t and they have plenty of other manipulations available in their bag of tricks instead. As another commenter wrote, they, meaning the gov’t leaders of the world’s major powerblocs can all make some new surprise announcement to turn the tables on a trend. If 2 or 3 of them get together to make policy announcements in unison, much more so.

    Ok, so let’s ask the question:

    If we have a fundamental scenario of interest rates / yields remaining low because they must, combined with currencies devaluing, then what are the counterbalancing assets that of course will go up?

    Gold, commodities, oil…right?

    I will repeat the point that the rich are richer than ever the world over including America and that this is a large proportion of the world population, especially too with China’s nouveau rich sector reaching down even into the hundreds of millions in their lower and middle class. See: http://www.rickackerman.com/2010/08/the-15-trillion-home-equity-question/

    Ergo, everyone else, particularly Americans/Europeans are going to have a worsening lifestyle decline in the coming years. Asians/Chinese are much more used to living a bare-bones type of life, they can handle it emotionally much more easily. The Western common man will suffer so much in the coming years. The “China” local street merchant and house-sharing lifestyle will return to America more and more. Another typical American just lost his 2nd vehicle with the $300 car payment to a repossession and happily let it go. Soon their son & wife will probably be living in the 3rd bedroom. This is the nature of the trend that is going to escalate across the American middle and lower class landscape, whilst the 100 million comfortable and rich Americans will more and more keep to themselves and be fine. Such is life.

    Cheers, Mario

    • Rick Ackerman October 9, 2010, 1:08 am

      The Fed can do whatever it likes with administered, nominal rates, but rates will still rise in real terms to crush, asphyxiate and obliterate debtors via deflation. That is what is happening, and it’s pretty obvious by now that the central bank’s efforts to counter deflation have been completely overwhelmed.