$120 Billion for Uber? Investors Must Be Out of Their Minds

The spectacular orgy of greed surrounding Uber’s impending IPO shows how out-of-whack valuations have gotten. Wall Street thinks the ride-hailing company could fetch as much as $120 billion when it is retailed to the rubes early next year. That’s nearly double the valuation of Uber’s last fundraising round just two months ago, according to the Wall Street Journal, and more than the combined value of General Motors, Ford and Fiat Chrysler. For further comparison, the biggest-ever deal in the defense sector, a proposed merger between Harris and L3 Technologies, would be worth a measly $33.5 billion. Are  investors out of their minds? Uber, after all, has little physical substance and no profits. It exists in the form of a smartphone application, a few office buildings and a global network of freelance drivers who struggle to make a living at it.

The fact that Uber hasn’t booked any profits is no drawback for Wall Street’s gifted pitch-men, who have always lived by P.T. Barnum’s dictum that there’s a sucker born every minute.  These shysters regard earnings for IPO companies as an abomination, since, once  a company starts making money, its shares can be marked-to-market to reflect a price/earnings ratio. The last thing in the world Uber insiders want is earnings, since they provide a reality check against whatever story deal-makers have concocted to hype the company’s supposedly limitless potential.

An Uber-Killing App Already Exists

Investors clamoring to pay $120 billion for Uber had better consider that the company’s future is just as vulnerable to disruptive new technologies as the taxi fleets Uber and Lyft have decimated. Are the yokels who will be bidding hand-over-fist for IPO shares aware there’s a phone application that makes it possible for anyone to start a ride-hailing company practically overnight? That’s right. The software handles every task that Uber’s does, soup-to-nuts, including insurance, mileage charges, routing, pickup and delivery.  Will Uber and Lyft be able to compete with 50 million scheming, dreaming entrepreneurs who can leap into the ride-hailing business and have a dozen subcontractors working for them with less work than it takes to run a hot dog cart?

A $120 billion valuation for Uber would be the slickest con-job ever foisted on retail investors. Under the circumstances, a stock-market crash before the IPO is probably the best thing that could happen to them, since it would bring the deal back down to earth, perhaps in the $15B-$20B range. That would still be absurd by the standards of yesteryear, when even the most innovative companies had to earn their way to success. No such demands are placed on hot upstarts these days, and that’s why this is not going to end well.

  • Pan October 18, 2018, 12:02 pm

    Dear John Jay,

    Here in Thailand we use the Uber equivalent called Grab. It’s very popular with us Faranges (Westerners) because we actually get an agreed fair price in advance as opposed to the usual attempt to rip off the foreigner confrontation and the driver actually understands where we want to go. So in terms of safety, Grab is far superior to hailing an ordinary taxi. But, and please forgive me for suggesting so, I can’t help think that anyone whose afraid of using Uber probably shouldn’t leave the house, what with all those rabid dogs running around and all that : )

  • none October 18, 2018, 8:59 am

    This is what Bear Market thinking brings to the front and center:

    Just had too…:)

    Kristen Bell voices concern about message ‘Snow White’ sends to daughters

    https://www.foxnews.com/entertainment/kristen-bell-voices-concern-about-message-snow-white-sends-to-daughters

    Comments

    MESSAGE TO REAL MEN FROM a REAL WOMAN:

    If I am ever poisoned and a kiss will revive me, please do it.

    Bull Market thinking is Faith and Love.
    Bear Market thinking is Fear and Hate.

    Have another great day Rick.

  • Farmer October 18, 2018, 8:05 am

    Absolutely right Rick. Here in Kenya there are more than 5 Uber type apps available to hail Boda-Boda’s (motorcycle taxis) that I know of. More are threatening to spring up as the explosive growth of 2 wheeled transport in Nairobi has doubled in the past year to 159,000 registered bikes. Uber has a share but it’s competition is fierce and there really is no moat to protect their idea from upstart disruption. I suspect this is already reflected in Ubers global numbers. They are going to the share market in a greedy rush just in time to experience their predictable irrelevance.

  • John Jay October 18, 2018, 12:21 am

    LOL!
    Remember zzzzbest, the carpet cleaning stock?
    Remember breexx, the gold mining stock?
    How about JDSU in the dotcom bubble?
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JDSU

    There is quite a list of stocks just like those three!
    You can still make a boatload of money on wacky stocks if you are nimble and disciplined!

    My disbelief is actually focused on who would take a chance on Uber, Lyft, etc. to save ten bucks?
    I see an awful lot of assaults and rapes everyday in the news related to that industry.
    In my mind you are essentially hitch-hiking, with all the risks that hitch-hiking brings.
    I feel a lot safer in a cab that has a license to do business with mandated personal injury insurance.
    But I am a lot more risk averse than the average carefree American living his life as an 8 year old!
    It’s a free country!
    Yay!

  • none October 17, 2018, 7:54 pm

    X Government workers gone to the private side more than likely, no one can beat the U.S. Government PE Ratio, or Book Value. Well maybe Venezuela.

    Have a great day Rick.